The Spoony Experiment

Because I want to see Doctor Ross return to kill some zombies, that’s why.

by Spoony on May 29, 2009 · View Comments

ER of the Dead

ER is a show that went on way too long, well past its expiration date. Sure, we’ve had hospital dramas since the beginning of television, but let’s be real, it’s a show about doctors and sick people, and once you’ve done the usual bits about doctors with drug addictions, romantic liasons, doctors euthanizing patients, doctors unable to cope with the stress or guilt of losing patients, and all that, there’s only so long you can torture these poor characters before you just plumb run out of ideas. Hell, even House M.D. has run out of wacky, impossible-to-diagnose bullshit. When you reach that point you start getting into some seriously loony stunt-writing to fill time.

And believe me, ER started doing that around its seventh season. It went on for fifteen years. Fifteen years. That’s just insane. Can you imagine the stuff they had to pull out of their asses to go that long? Eventually they realized the only way to keep it fresh was to circulate new characters in, and that meant phasing old characters out. Remember Doctor Romano?

I do. It’s probably the most cracktastic, insane soap opera death I’ve ever seen. If you remember that episode of Friends where Joey’s doctor character falls down an elevator shaft, that’s NOTHING in comparison. Doctor Romano got horribly maimed by a helicopter.

Twice.

We’re talking about a long-running storyline where a doctor got his arm amputated by a tail rotor, developed an irrational fear of helicopters… which turned out to not be that irrational when weeks later, another helicopter proceeded to get caught in sudden windshear and dropped directly on his head.

Thing is, though, it really should have saved ER. Come on, now, that’s undoubtedly the most retarded thing you’ve ever heard, but it’s also AWESOMELY retarded. You just don’t see this kind of shit every day. And I’ll be honest, it took balls to kill off a character in an otherwise serious drama in such a hilarious fashion. No brains, but massive cojones. If ER had only embraced that dark side, become some nightmare, bizarre parody of its former greatness, it might have evolved into something even greater! Oh, it would have totally alienated its old audience but found a new one altogether. It has the virtue of being new and original, instead of shambling onward for ten years, unwatched, a shell of its former self.

ER needed to do something insane, something radical, something unlike any hospital drama before it had attempted. It had mined out every other hospital drama storyline long ago, so why not get crazy? How crazy? Sometimes jumping the shark isn’t just inevitable, it’s absolutely called-for. Hell, I wanna jump that fucking shark on an ACME rocket with my hair on fire.

Sixteenth season: the zombie apocalypse hits. We’re there on Day 1: patients come in with severe fevers and dementia, most suffering from bite wounds and claw marks that show advanced stages of infection and skin necrosis despite claims that they were bitten that morning. The doctors aren’t stupid, they know what this looks like, even if they’re not willing to put anything on paper yet. They isolate the victims and start running blood tests, alerting security to keep an eye on them.

Things snowball fast, though. The ER gets swamped with injuries from riots, more attack victims, and people fearing for their safety. People are demanding answers and treatment, and a fearful mob quickly turns to a violent panic. The doctors are even temporarily forced to evacuate until the police (already stretched thin) can restore order.

Things start looking up once the National Guard responds and sets up a military cordon and mass triage in the parking lot, but already there’s talk of evacuation as the infection spreads like wildfire outside the cordon. Nobody knows what’s going on, as the national media seems to be completely ignoring the crisis, perhaps as the result of a government blackout. It leads the doctors into thinking that perhaps the infection is localized to the city, a fear that is confirmed when the National Guard commander is informed that the regular army is setting up a quarantine zone.

(This leads to several interesting subplots where the guard commander starts to fear from his communications with his superiors that the military is preparing to eradicate the infection by nuking the city. Additionally, some of the doctors realize that if the infection is local to the city, then there may be hope of a cure if they can find Patient Zero, if any of them have the balls to venture outside the military cordon.)

Days pass, and the situation grows even more bleak. The hospital is nearly overrun from within when bodies from the hospital morgue– bodies that had no contact with other infected– start to rise and attack. The doctors are now completely baffled, and there’s growing sentiment among some that they should try to take the medivac helicopter to safety, infection be damned. The military quarantine would likely shoot down such an attempt, but try explaining that to a fearful mob of patients.

Salvation finally arrives when the military starts dropping supplies, food, and ammo, as well as relief paratroopers and a new group of doctors. It seems like good news, until it turns out that these new doctors and soldiers have little interest in the hospital’s problems. They immediately commandeer an entire floor and start moving equipment in. Every day, they start asking for specific patients by name and taking them away, by force if necessary. These patients never return, and all day and all night, the helicopters fly in and out, taking sealed crates away and bringing new ones back.

One day, they all leave. They pack up their gear just before dawn and fly off, never to return. The military radios go deathly quiet. The scheduled airdrop never arrives. The next morning, the National Guard commander is found dead, a smoking gun in his hand. The best case scenario is that they’ve been abandoned to their fates. The worst case? Does anyone else hear an airplane?

  • Share/Bookmark
  • ER + what sounds like Shadowrun's "Bug City" + zombie Paul McCrane = good family fun
  • James Collinge
    The funny thing is, a Hospital Drama just like the one Spoony describes here has actually been made as a parody of low budget sci-fi shows that were popular in the 80s, search on youtube for 'Garth Marenghi's Darkplace' and prepare for the insanity.
  • OK, FUCKING EPIC, and you could turn this into ur own movie, just rewrite the bits about any specific ER chars, this is more amazing than PIE or CAKE its better than PIKE i love this its amazing
  • This is awesome. I think if you were to drop the whole connection to E.R and maybe try to change up the aspects that sound similar to "Outbreak" then you could have a pretty solid epic zombie movie on your hands! Hell I'd even help you if I didn't live in Scotland.
  • Mycroft
    I know these aren't too popular on here (compared to your videos) but please write more of them. They're awesome.
  • Selfish
    I really didn't need another reason to hate ER.
    Not that I've ever seen a full episode...
  • FionordeQuester
    Can someone please answer my question?
  • Taliesin
    Is it wrong that so far, every single one of your ideas sounds completely awesome?
  • Asimov
    Spoony, wtf are you talking about you shouldn't write screenplays? That is some awesome shit right there. I never watched ER, but I would if that was the plot!

    Inserting Zombies into anything automatically makes it THAT much better. Pride and Prejudice and Zombies was AWESOME. It turns something unwatchable or unreadable into something palatable. You think the publishers of PPZ limited themselves by saying they shouldn't do something like that? Heck no.

    You should have more confidence in your abilities to make things better. I liked your version of terminator, it just needed to be fleshed out a bit.
  • Kraken
    I don't see a problem with shows running on and on. When you are cycling new characters in and out on a constant basis, it becomes, structurally, less like a traditional US drama and more like a British soap opera. You're following CHARACTER arcs and when you constantly retire old characters and introduce new ones, there's no real reason it couldn't continue indefinitely. Look at soaps like Eastenders, that's been running several times a week (we're up to 4 currently) for twenty four years, that's 3787 episodes and counting. Corination street? even longer. Even Casualty, our long running medical drama, has been running for nearly 700 episodes. Not to say those shows are high art or anything, but some formats lend themselves to indefinite runs. You don't NEED to re-invent the wheel, you can show similar emergency incidents to, say, 5 years ago, and with a new cast of characters reacting and dealing with it in a new way, it can still work and not bore the audience.

    Anyway, that said, lose the "canon" ER connection and I think this could make a cool movie or miniseries. Zombie/monster attacks seen from an unconventional perspective are pretty popular at the moment; Cloverfield (average guy on the street), Dead set (zombie apocalypse and Big Brother contestants), Sean of the dead (zombie romantic comedy). etc, and the hospital setting would be a cool take on things.
  • Chibito
    Well it's not like a zombie apocalypse episode could make the series worse right?
  • FionordeQuester
    "Salvation finally arrives when the military starts dropping supplies, food, and ammo, as well as relief paratroopers and a new group of doctors. It seems like good news, until it turns out that these new doctors and soldiers have little interest in the hospital’s problems. They immediately commandeer an entire floor and start moving equipment in. Every day, they start asking for specific patients by name and taking them away, by force if necessary. These patients never return, and all day and all night, the helicopters fly in and out, taking sealed crates away and bringing new ones back."

    "One day, they all leave. They pack up their gear just before dawn and fly off, never to return. The military radios go deathly quiet. The scheduled airdrop never arrives. The next morning, the National Guard commander is found dead, a smoking gun in his hand. The best case scenario is that they’ve been abandoned to their fates. The worst case? Does anyone else hear an airplane?"

    Does this mean that the ER doctors are either going to be killed by the zombies, or killed by the army?
  • Minsky
    Addendum: This, as well as many of your other 'Reasons' writings could actually, under certain circumstances, take off or be successful.

    As you likely know (or at least are aware of by now) many people really dig on zombies or the undead in general.

    However, I think you'd need to include a few Mengle types-y'know, the sadistic and cold doctors who take the undead plague as a chance to practice their darker desires, like splicing zombies together to make a "super zombie" or something equally nasty. They could abduct healthy victims and subject them to either an injection or a bite from one of the infected to see how the process works firsthand or (as per Day of the Dead) attempt to perfect a docile and compliant ghoul (and)or attempt to make an army of loyal zombies to enact some sort of take-over-the-world scenario.

    You could even have a parallel show wherein it deals with the local police force and how they treat the growing situation.

    Just think of the possibilities, man!

    Of course, without creative plot twists and writing, the show would last for (at best) one season, but what a season it could be!

    Noodle that one around, Satchmo.

    By the way, have you (or anyone else) seen Cemetary Man, or read the source material-an Italian comic called Dylan Dog? The comic has just been reprinted in the US for the first time in about a decade and is a must for fans of Paranormal Detectives like Steve Niles' Cal McDonald/Criminal Macabre series or Mike Mignola's Hellboy/B.P.R.D. series. It'll knock your socks on your ass!

    They're dead. They're...all messed-up.
  • Minsky
    This first started to sound like Von Trier's Hospital (not to be confused with the americanized 'Stephen King presents' version (saw a few eps of it, but just didn't get as interested as I did with the original).

    Then with the inclusion of zombies, it sounded like E.R. meets The Walking Dead.

    However, I've got a question for you (that probably will never be answered): If you were to cliche the undead into one of two groups: Night of the Living Dead -OR- Return of the Living Dead zombies, which would you choose?

    See, on one hand, you've got your slow, weak shambling flesh-eaters that can only be destroyed by damaging their brains.

    On the other: Fast, smart, normal human-strengh, sentient brain-eaters...oh yeah, and they talk and can't really be destroyed-or else the trioxin (or whatever you'd prefer to make corpses animate) is spread to further the plague.

    Send more paramedics
  • B
    Now, that would be the best possible season 16 /ever/. And i agree with DelVaro, you've actually got an original zombie plot on your hands. We want more! Future video, perhaps? *hopes*
  • DelVaro
    wow dude, this is an original plot for a zombie outbrake movie! :D sell this thing and earn a lot of money! :P OR direct the movie yourself to make it shity-proof
  • Terry
    Make it part of a World War Z story.
  • Newt
    Amen! All Hail, the spoony one!
  • FunkyChunkyDude
    Fuck, I'd watch it.
  • DrGero
    Fun read. It really strikes me as some out there fanfiction, but the type I'd like to give a read.
  • Dinodain
    You had me at Zombie Apocalypse. I would love to see this idea on television, not a lot of zombie stories from the point of view of Doctors (or at least not to my knowledge). This would be interesting, and fun to watch.
  • A
    I never watched E.R. but I thought this might be an interesting way to continue spoony's idea. After the army people leave have some the uninfected fly away to a remote island. Then later on have an airplane land near the hospital to give the uninfected people in the hospital the vaccine. However, the vaccine that was supposed to be for the uninfected people who flew away to the island expires and is saved in a containment room with a video tape of the affect area.
    Back on the island the uninfected start to show signs of becoming zombies but nothing comes of it. Later on the creatures of the island turn into zombies and a few escape the island infecting areas of the world. The new strains of the zombie virus mutate before vaccines can be made. Food recalls on aired on the news and people begin to starve to death and dehydrate as the viruses spread to plant life and water sources.
    Eventually all matter on earth is in a process of decay.
    At one point a piece of space debris drifts into the outskirts of Earth's gravitational field and picks up a version of the virus. Then the debris continues drifting through space. This spreads the virus to new planets. The different environments cause mutations in the virus strain.
    As worlds are being destroyed a group of interplanetary scientists join forces in a space station. They go to earth and retrieve the information that was preserved by the doctors and use it to create vaccines. However, they run into time constraints again as the vaccines expire before the vaccines can reach all the infected.
    The doctors are unable to save the universe. As a result of planets going into decay the planets and related stars explode burning the whole universe.
  • Grr, so frustrated speaking in Hulk-like childish tones! STAC SMASH!

    Aka, the boob forgot the 'n' in 'damn'.

    Stac
  • Objecterror
    Brilliant. Really Brilliant.
  • This would be the only thing that could ever intice me to watch ER. Damn you for exploiting my weakness for the undead Spoony. Dam you to hell.

    Stac
  • jadedcorliss
    Most shows hit their expiration dates at about 5-8 years, don't you think?
  • CapnG
    NOW you're living up to the premise of these articles.
  • finalsight
    Lol i've never watched ER but i have to say that the whole Dr Vs Helicopter was sure brilliance.
  • Meta
    This is sounding strangely like something that should've been the plot for Quarantine, without the shaky camera and first-person perspective. But in hindsight, it does seem kind of a bad idea, only in the context of making it hilariously bad, and seems more like a serious drama, but it really all depends on how it is executed. I don't completely understand the events leading to the ending though. It sounds like they took the infected civilians, stuffed them into sealed crates, flew off, and after a few runs never came back to rescue the non-infected. It sounds interesting, but I don't know, there's something about it that seems all too familiar.
  • Ed
    I think E.R. would've been perfect for this idea, given the pre-established histories that most of the cast would have (which would also lend weight to the inevitable horrible character deaths), but really...just the IDEA of a zombie apocalypse movie that focuses on the staff of a hospital has a lot of merit. I think playing it straight would be the way to go; no doctors wielding flamethrowers or souped up Battle Ambulances (sorry, Ninja Moogle)...just a ground-level perspective about what this would be like. (So pretty much a chapter of World War Z, yeah.)

    Anyway, your "crappy" ideas continue to be awesome. Keep it up, man.
blog comments powered by Disqus