Pumpkinhead – Benzaie’s Outtakes

My heart made that noise when I discovered that the term 'booby prize' was something of a misnomer.

I would have used Dragonball Evolution / Goatee and blue alien chic.

Some of these were way better than the ones you ended up using. I woulda went with Sales Tax, or DragonBall, and the blue alien chick or Atlas.

You gotta love how Benzaie planned out all these lines before the final product. haha

I have to agree with spoony's Commentary and say Beary's voice is actually cute. lol

My heart did not make that noise when this became a meme, but the spoony one makes it now.

My heart made that noise when I found out that I had a Philosophy Midterm on the same day as a Physics 3 Test. The Spoony One makes it now.

Oof, you lost your save in Animal Crossing? Wow, my heart goes out to you.
I actually didn't mind Raiden being the main char in MGS2. Didn't bother me.

I think you should have gone with the Twilight one.

My heart made that noise when I saw Steve Martin playing Inspector Clouseau. The Spoony One makes it now.

My heart made that noise when I slowly realized Raiden was the main character of MGS 2. The Spoony One makes it now.

my heart made that noise when I found out they were remaking A Nightmare on Elm Street and then again moments after when I discovered it will be directed by Michael Bay

dude, losing your animal crossing is harsh! you'd have to play for another year and a half!

Jim: $20, plus lunch for the winner.
Mind you, $20 is a lot for a high school student.

How much was the wager for?

Jim: I was stupid enough to mke a bet with an Obama supporter at my school. I honeslty thought that 2008 would prove the Bradley Effect and that I would get my female vice president.

Jael: You too? You won't believe how much I lost in Election Day bets. I was SURE that at least one state would go to the libertarians. Maybe in 2012...

My heart made that noise when I watched Indiana Jones 4.
My heart made that noise when I saw Indiana Jones get raped on that one episode of South Park
My heart mad that noise when I read Breaking Dawn
My heart made that noise when Harry didn't die at the end of Deathly Hallows and I was out twent buck due to a bet,
My heart made that noise when I found out that Rachelle Leferve was replaced by Bryce Dallas Howard for Eclipse.
My heart made that noise when I lost my bet on the 2008 Elections

my heart made that noise as i experienced endless eight in haruhi season 2, the spoony one makes it now.

my heart made that noise as i watched batman and robin, the spoony one makes it now.

are you kidding me? i have to go rescue chloe from the train! nothing bad could ever happen in that level! :)

My heart made that noise when I learned that "Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts" was going to be about nothing but building weird vehicles.

My heart made that noise when my laptop's hard drive burned out and I lost all my porn.

My heart made that noise when I fought Hume in Eternal Daughter. The Spoony One makes it now.

or

My heart made that noise when I found out Maximo was just like Super Ghouls and Ghosts. The Spoony One makes it now.

or (and this one is worst for me by far)

My heart made that noise when the Ayleid doors glitched in the console version of Oblivion, preventing my lv 34 Archmage from completing the main game. The Spoony One makes it now.

My heart made that noise when I first heard Bioshock 2 was going to be delayed..

My heart made that noise when I realised MGS4 ruined the series storyline
OR
My heart made that noise when I realised the RE series has now become a rail shooter.

Here's a couple:

"My heart made that noise when I saw the original ending of Neon Genesis Evangelion. The Spoony One makes it now..."

"My heart made that noise when I saw Devastator's 'package' in Transformers 2. The Spoony One makes it now..."

"My heart made that noise when my brother lost my copy of The Neverhood. The Spoony One makes it now..."

Ohh ohh I got another one!

My heart made that noise when I first saw a PETA ad on The Spoony Experiment's sidebar, The Spoony One makes it now...

My heart made that noise when I was banned from Xbox Live. The Spoony One makes it now.

My heart made that noise when I saw the first 30 seconds of the Nostalgia Critic's review of Congo. The Spoony One makes it now...

You should have used the one with Twilight or Dragonball Evolution.

My heart made that noise when I saw the Devil May Cry anime. The Spoony One makes it now.

My heart made that noise when I found out Fatal Frame 4 wouldn't be released in North America.

Seriously.

Please put "My heart made that noise when..." on a shirt.

ROFL That line can be used forever.

Yea!! Firefly reference!

My heart made that noise when Firefly was cancelled which later turned into a joyous sound for Serenity before my heart started to bleed at the rising action.

(in reference to Wash and Book)

Meh.

My heart made that noise when- Wait I'mma let you finished, but Benzaie had the best 'My heart made that noise' slogan of all time, of all time!

My heart made that noise when I watched The Matrix Revolutions for the first time, the Spoony One makes it now.

My heart made that noise when Harmony Gold sued the makers of the rebooted Mechwarrior, the Spoony One makes it now.

My heart made that noise when they forgot to put bacon on my cheeseburger, the Spoony One makes it now.