Reminds me of Celebrity Roast from The Onion Movie. I loved that movie, go watch it if you haven’t ;D

Necro Critic is so annoying …
I had to skip almost 1/4 of his video just not to hear his monotone voice to get to see the material the video was about.

Yes!

Griff = awesome.

I liked the space mountain joke…
WOOOOOO

Necro Critics voice cracked so much I think he hit puberty in mid review.

Then again what better way for a young man to learn then from a ride on space mountain.

Wooo~

MOTHER FUCKER FRONT PAGE! WHOOOO!

I officially feel like Space Mountain is officially my penis.

Oh my. I peed a little.

I feel bad for being so dorky.

Oh God, the Necro Critic was unfunny, really annoying and terribly whiny. I got a headache for listening to that

Oh God, the Necro Critic was unfunny, really annoying and terribly whiny. I got a headache for listening to that

i didn’t really like the whole top ten worst jokes. Some were meant to be bad jokes, and some weren’t very funny but they weren’t what i would consider fodder for something like that. i dunno. he was boring too. like watching prepubescent mayonnaise. incisently, that song is hot. do they have a website somewhere?

Why the hell are you all focusing on the negative. Watch the damn roast.

^

What he said.

Awesome! This video made my day/morning.

Awesome! This video made my day/morning.

Make our own Spoony tributes and ribbings, eh? I’ll need 50 feet of good and sturdy pvc pipe, a stard 12 inch ruler, hot resin, a few excess metal scraps, and finally a blue-tongued skink. Let the bludgeoning BEGIN! My new skink, Sir Cogsweller, commands it!

Cmon, the second vid wasn’t THAT bad

Did not enjoy Necro critic, mostly because some of the jokes he chose where funny in an immature way, and so I didn’t have a problem with that.

I recently had the idea to make a video “My top 10 favorite moments from the Spoony Experiment”.

Also, I need to start randomly yelling “Phantasmagoria” too!

And the Spoony-Bum isn’t that horrible! I like him. What is everyone’s problem with it?
Also, I would defend every single one of these jokes except for the Mormon prom.
In all honesty, the Necro Critic reminds me of a more nitpicky version of Film Brain. Spoony’s “bad jokes” were the most entertaining part of the video.

I recently had the idea to make a video “My top 10 favorite moments from the Spoony Experiment”.

Also, I need to start randomly yelling “Phantasmagoria” too!

And the Spoony-Bum isn’t that horrible! I like him. What is everyone’s problem with it?
Also, I would defend every single one of these jokes except for the Mormon prom.
In all honesty, the Necro Critic reminds me of a more nitpicky version of Film Brain. Spoony’s “bad jokes” were the most entertaining part of the video.

Concerning the Necro Critic’s top list, #1 and #3 were among the most hilarious jokes the Spoony One has ever made. #8 was the worst one really. The others on the list were not that bad. Actually I like puns more than anything. I also hated it when Spoony slapped himself for some jokes he made in the Phantasmagoria 2 Let’s Play. Those jokes were not bad, those were the best jokes in the Let’s Play!

Huh…you know I thought it would be funny for people to mock Noah for three years of internet comedy…but it isn’t.

Also, Necro Critic, “The Defense Rests” joke in North is still the worst joke of all time, imitating Doug’s joke in the North Review doesn’t make any difference.

Don’t Listen to them! We love you Spoony!!

OK. Now I’m officially sending a feature request to blip for a speed up button. This was so god damn atrocious I had around a dozen “Get on with it” Monty Python flashbacks.

And leave the Spoony Bum alone! LEAVE HIM ALONE!

who are these unkowns roasting spoony? What the hell have they done?

The end of the Dirty Harry review wasn’t a Sopranos reference, it was a reference to the way the level continued past the boss, then ended abruptly. Any resemblance to TV series, airing or canceled, is purely coincidental.

Also, I laughed my ass off at “Space Mountain”. The delivery really sold that one. As Casper would say:
TIMING!

Finally, the horrible puns followed by slapping is a reference to MST3k/Rifftrax– especially in the latter, they do that quite oftten. The difference is that they riff with 3 people, so they police each other when it comes to slappings.

Damn that Necro Critic was horrible. Only nr.10 on his list made some sense and the rest was just boring and utterly subjective nitpicking. He could at least try to make me care about the rest of the list.

I’d have trouble watching an hour of Spoony at one time, so there’s no way I’m watching an hour of badly edited footage of people I don’t know badly making fun of a guy.

And that albino guy is creepy as shit. I feel like he’s going to murder me in my sleep. And he doesn’t understand humour.

Wow that’s the first time I’ve heard the intro song in its entirety; awesome tune!

Awesome roasting people. An hour probably not well spent, but at least enjoyed.
Well, partially. And hey, I’m not even a forum go-er.

But as you all said, here’s for 3(+?!) more years of Spoony, chained to the Internet on a free site like our personal critic-slave. Those of you wishing him greater success better stop it; we’ll have to pay to see this stuff if he’s on TV!

But in all seriousness it’s been a merry three years and I hope it keeps on going.

I feel bad, I liked Spoony bum :(. And I also enjoyed you playing with dolls in the Hells Kitchen review. God I must be so lame.

Don’t know why people hate the dollies so much :D i loved them. Also weren’t the two jokes in SWAT review an in-Joke :) You know, like they were classic lame police vs. robber jokes.

Good morning Spoony and fellow Spooners,

Actually, the Bayou Billy review treated us to the begging-to-be-taken-out-of-context line “I just hope I can beat a turkey out of this guy’s ass, so I can eat it.” (or something like that). So even in his earliest, pre-script days, Spoony was still great.

Anyway, three years? Pity I haven’t been around longer. But that can be remedied. Thanks for the memories, Spoony. Skronk!

Holy crap this Necro guy is boring as shit.

That Necro dude doesn’t know what he’s talking about.The SWAT jokes and Space Mountain bit were terrible on purpose.They were using the anti-joke principle and the playing with dolls bit was supposed to be funny because it’s sad and has a couple of good lines in it.And the gay chorus in FF8 had me cracking up when I first heard it.

Man I thought this is a one review, that would be ok, but this guy has a whole bunch of them. You kinda rip off all the other guys. This is just plain boring. I think that with so many people trying to do reviews there’s really not much to add. At least go for something original like Linkara with comics, there’s really nothing more to say about old video games and movies…

Man I thought this is a one review, that would be ok, but this guy has a whole bunch of them. You kinda rip off all the other guys. This is just plain boring. I think that with so many people trying to do reviews there’s really not much to add. At least go for something original like Linkara with comics, there’s really nothing more to say about old video games and movies…

Whaaaaaat!? This guy’s hating on the Hell’s Kitchen review? I love the doll bits!
And the Spoony Bum, too? This Nerco guy is off his rocker!

Necro Critic loses because he is 1. not funny at all 2. he totally dissed 9. Why not just skip ahead to 10 and leave the gamers with at least an inch of self respect with their asses in tact?

HAPPY THREE YEARS oh man I’ve been watching you for two and a half years orz…

Dude why didnt Benzaie roast you?

I’m pretty sure that Necro’s video wasn’t meant to be taken seriously. It’s an aniversary roast video, you’re supposed to make fun of the subject.

Saying that, if it was serious… FUCK YOU NECRO! I’ve never lauged harder at something than I did during the action figure scenes.

Yeah, the space mountain joke was creepy.

Thanks for 3 years of hilarity spoony :0)
Your the funnyest guy on the internet (except for the nerd of course)!

Oh what the hell, the spoony experiment has been up for already 3 years ? can’t believe i didn’t discovered it earlier !
Anyway, good job with the roasting guys, although i didn’t really like the idea of telling bad things about someone you appreciate … But hey, seeing that made me proud of being such a spoony fan i couldn’t see all these flaws myself !

Just wanted to let you all know that a roast doesn’t neccessarily mean you hate certain parts about the person. In fact, it’s good form to find out what the person will let you make fun of first. A roast is supposed to be a session of lighthearted barbs. Just remember that we’re kidding about all of this stuff, and we don’t really hate a lot of the things about Spoony that we mention.

Mostly.

Wow, this Necro critic is such a tool. Its not that he made this list, its just his voice and personality (or lack of) wa so irritating to listen to.

The roast was funny though.

Why do people hate the spoony bum i like him thought he was going to play boredgames that everyone hates and make it look like they where lots of fun

Necro critic chose wrong jokes. Some even were funny or meant to be unfunny.

”But enough about the irate gamer.”
That was one of the funniest thing i have heard today.

Oh man, I just learned what the theme song is about from watching this. And that its sung by a chick. It realy shows how colored my perspective on the world is when I think thats just a really girl sounding dude singing it.

These people are unbearably annoying.

More you Spoony, keep your jerkass fans away.

nerco critic…. That was so dumb, I stopped watching at #4. I think it was interesting to pick out bad jokes but the worst one of all was the fact he made the video and thinks he’s actually funny when doing it. Sunglasses? Why so he can try and trick us that he’s not always looking down reading off of a paper. Lame enough so in the future I will make it a point to avoid anything else done by him.

Who’s the hot chick with the shades?

What’s title of the song at 14:00?

I stopped watching about half way through. That roast was so boring and unfunny. Plus already know you’re awesome Noah :)

I stopped watching about half way through. That roast was so boring and unfunny. Plus already know you’re awesome Noah :)

Hi Noah, YOU ROCK ¡¡¡
Happy 3 years

Saludos desde Chile
Aunque no lo creas, aca en el fin del mundo tienes un fan..but how? WITH SCIENCE OF COURSE¡¡¡ ….and the internet xD.

ADIOS

Ouch! Roasted themselves really.

“That roast was so boring and unfunny.”

Couldn’t agree more… And man i feel sorry for that Necro critic, he’s actually so bad it becomes kinda amusing. He’s almost like a parody of these “wannabe critic” reviewers.

@Daku14

NIce to have some Chilean fans!

Saludos compadre!!!

The worst Spoony’s joke is million times better than Irate Gamer’s best joke.

Worst joke ever, Necro Critic? It wasn’t even the worst joke in your review…that honor goes to your opening joke about the Irate Gamer. Seriously though, while the Sopranos cutoff gag, the Hell’s Kitchen stuff, and the “snakes” line were indeed weaksauce, the others were either passable (such as the FF8 joke), deliberate (the SWAT puns), or downright true (have you ever BEEN to a Mormon prom?).

I’m starting to think these guest appearances are spoony’s version of the whole “I hang out with ugly girls, so I look better” thing

on the plus side, it is working

Ugh, that necro critic, I think I got tired of the cracking voice, sunglasses and canned ham humor about halfway into the video. Anyway, congrats on making it three years spoony.

A happy merry 3-years-ish Spoony :D I’ve only been tuning in for a year and a half, but I’m catching up!
The roast was ok. More impressive in who it set out to ‘honour’ rather than entertaining, but it was
a sweet thing to do :] so kudos!

Necro critic… hmmm.. I gave him the benefit of the doubt and checked out some of his other reviews
before commenting. In all honesty, I don’t like him :/ he’s boring and a bit pretentious. His video on this
site missed a lot of the points in some of the jokes; like how some of them were meant to be bad and cheesy.
Also I kinda found it sad that he took his time out to find the worst jokes you’ve ever done and still failed haha.

But I digress, the reason we’re here is to celebrate 3(ish) years of the experiment :D CONGRATS and may there be many more! Woot!!!

Charlie, I am so disappointed that your link doesn’t lead to the splooge I was promised. How un-fuckin’-believable!

if ever a roast needed gilbert gottfried, it is this one.

Now I have to watch this… ^^

Don’t kill me, but I kinda disliked this Necro Critic guy. The “badness” of Spoony’s jokes was all over the place, so the list was in large part a hit and miss. However the worse thing was his constant overpronnounciation, no sense of tempo or timing in his speech and let’s not forget tge somewhat skewed perception of his on-line persona (and here I was thinking *I* was creepy). The only creepy thing was his admittance that he watched Spoony’s “The Thing” review over 50 times. Hey, I enjoy Spoony’s work, but 50 times? If I was Spoony, I wouldn’t be flattered as much as I would be halfway through an application for a restraining order. Bottom line, he’s just not someone I would be interested in seeing more of, and have only endured through this particular video because I enjoyed revisiting Spoony’s older stuff.

So… thumbs up for being brave to stand up in front of the camera and subsequently a face a hell of a lot of folks who would more likely then not simply criticize (kind of like what I just did in the previous paragraph), but I think some major improvements are in order for Necro Critic’s material to be on par with Spoony and the rest of his gang.

As for the other minor 3-year anniversary thingie… what other to say then Spoony CONGRATS!! And keep it up, hope in the end it pays off much more then you ever expected it to do.

Ok, so I didn’t watch the roast, but I did watch Necro Critic. And ouch, man. Really? That was it?

I realise that this is semi-in-jest, with the anniversary and all, but still. Half of those jokes weren’t that bad (certainly not as bad as some of yours), but more than that I think you missed the point. Dirty Harry review ending doesn’t make sense huh? Considering he was making the point that the first level just ended abruptly, it seemed to make perfect sense to me, or was I just watching a different review? Also, making fun of the Spoonybum seems pretty cheap considering that Spoony has ALREADY MADE FUN OF IT. Not to mention the whole idea of a reviewer reviewing a reviewer just hurts my brain. To sum up my feelings on Necro Critic – “Dis guy, is un-fucking believable”.

Anyway, Happy Anniversary Spoony, and I look forward to another 3 glorious years. Now get on with Ripper so we can get a few more of those Walken impersonations.

lol bob sagets roast was so funny, I would steal everything from that one too if I was as untalented as you guys.

Spoony rocks, you other guys do not. Especially Sage, hes the most boring guy of TGWTG and whats up with his eyes? Seriously ..

Only watched the Necro one.

The only really bad joke was the one about Punky Brewster’s boobs. That was over the top.

and btw who seriously watched the roast completley, its one hour with people nobody gives a fuck about

ONE HOUR!

what in the name of god

I actually know who Helldragon is! I’m ONE of those half-dozen people! YAY!

Sorry, the roast was long and boring. Many of the guys tried to make fun of Spoony but they failed. Come on, everyone could say “I hate you because you are stupid” or “AVGN is the best because is God/Jesus”. This is something that a five years old child would say. The only one entertaining was Griff Morivan.

Reading alot of these comments makes me lose even more faith in the human race. So many of the people commenting on this video think the whole thing is SERIOUS. Jesus Christ, the video is on SPOONYS site, posted with his blessing. If this were a real roast do you think Spoony would want in on. People like that shouldnt be allowed near a computer, allowed to go outside or have conversations with anyone. While the internet did allow us to be introduced to people like Spoony, its also proof that there are many assholes out there with no concept of satire or humor and take things as they see them. Bless those poor souls and their sad little minds.

Great video and I’m glad to see SOME people actually got it.

Yeeeaaah, I just couldn’t watch the Necro Critic, he didn’t sound the least bit interested or enthused in his own video.

In fact, you can see how bored he is thirteen seconds in when he readies his right hand to jerk off.

You know, I don’t mind Spoony bum as a tribute character and he is a decent imersination, I just don’t like the lack of originality though “Necro critic” is pretty unoriginal, it even has the Nostaligia Critics initials (Doug NC then the other NC), and is the Necro Critic supposed to be some goth surfer dude or something? Please Spoony, you may enjoy these other reviewers and giving them publicity is nice but maybe theres a reason they’re not well known, to put it in laymans terms “THEY SUCK!”.

This NC saying “Not everything spoken can be funny” gives a good example for his point, his attempts at being funny while trying to read a script are either forced or he goes monotone for no reason (hint: Talking to a cameras not his thing nor is entertaining). He should stick to just the clips or text because he’s not crazy enough to talk normally to a camera. Some of SOs jokes like 8 were bad but thats a speedbump on a highway, NCs video is like an unpaved road made of boulders. Whats so bad about 5? That was okay, not funny but not bad. No. 4 was bad but not awful, and 3? Bad or not it is clever! 2? Whys that so bad? No.1, Geez NC dosen’t understand humor seeing how he hates puns, that was funny.

Thats actually better then some of the Roasts you see on Comedy Central. You know the ones where 80% of its cussing and no one really knows who the heck their joking so they have to focus most their Jokes on the other roasters when we tuned in to see the target get joked. They make Dean martin throw up in his grave. This roast was decent. You earned it, man! I hope you many more years of excellent work.

Ps You are a lucky bastard to have a girlfriend that hot.

@Poipoi: That’s something we can all agree on. Especially Linkara.

Man, that was awful. But at least Spoony was big hearted enough not to tell them it was too awful to put on his site.

those guys couldnt roast a turkey

You know, I never thought the cutoff joke was a sopranos thing, so much as it was the way the level he’d just reviewed ended…. you know how it just suddenly petered out after playing some more sewers after the boss? I never made a sopranos connection there.

NECKBEARD. NECK. BEARD.

Congrats on the anniversary Spoony.

With that said… the roast was just overlong and unfunny. Sorry guys, it really didn’t work.
The Necro Critic’s presentation was so grating and stale I bailed around a minute in, never mind the Spoony joke list.

I never really understood what’s so funny about the whole Roast thing(yes I took the time to watch the whole thing). I dunno must be an American thing. I’m more of a British humor type of guy.
That said it’s good to see so many people give praise to Spoony and the Experiment.
Can’t believe it’s been 3 years already. I guess the saying ‘Time flies when you’re having fun’ really applies here.
Thank you Spoony for all the laughs and insight. I may not always agree with your opinions but you’re always entertaining and I hope you get to do this for many more years to come!

All hail the Spoony Experiment!

May the Spoony Experiment never end.

Oh god, the Necro critic was difficult to suffer through. That crackly pre-teen voice, along with the emo-esque dull tone and complete lack of humor punctuated by periods of intense social awkwardness…yikes.

Not to mention I really enjoyed the laundry jokes <_<

Congrats, Noah

Man, the Necro Critic should have shoved that bottle up his ass.

The only reason I sat through the roast is because I knew who Helldragon was. He was probably the funniest person, and that isn’t saying a lot due to the dismally boring rest of the roast.

Wow, I guess Spoony sets the bar so high that people have a hard time watching anything else.

Peeps know “Space Mountain” is a Ric Flair wrestling reference, right?

I really hope that you make amends now and help that poor Vista-kid. Shame on you, Spoony!

The fact that you are a uniter is unfortunately seldom recognized. You bring people from different worlds together and that is a very rare trait you share with other much adored and appreciated people throughout history.

I don’t think some of those Necrocritic complaints were great. I’m personally a guy who loves clever puns and the laundromat stuff was great.

Shame on Necro Critic ! He even picked out good jokes like when Spoony makes the bad puns in the laudromat it’s SUPPOSED to be bad. Get it ?

I knew that! Linkara is the MAN!

man that necrocritic guy’s voice is SOOOOOOoooooooo annoying!!! i could barely stand to watch the entire top 10.

I loved the space mountian joke. it is so over the top it is great not to mention using the Nature Boys WHOO.

Happy 3rd anniversary Spoony! Do we have to send you something made out of clay or something for that one?

Did the necro critic get that some of those jokes were supposed to be bad? I also didn’t watch the roast as soon as I saw it was an hour long.

Apparantly billy bayou was your first review… don’t think so This guy Is an Idiot at least spoony makes jokes… most are very funny

Necro critic is pathetic he didn’t get the laundry joke… Is he a dumbass?? YES but I don’t give a rats ass.

Oh yeah… and he’s fucking ugly

Well, the mean comments aside there were some good parts to the roast and it was enjoyable. I think ya’ll missed out though, as a roast should always have a rebuttal from the man of the hour and yours did not. Thats, um, generally how a roast works. Without it, it loses its flavor and is no longer a roast but merely a bunch of people lightheartedly making fun of something. If you’ll notice most roasts these days are for people that were famous, but no longer are. You couldnt get the famous person to show up otherwise I guess, i dont know, thats always been my guess as to why that is.

Anyway, without Spoony’s rebuttal this roast is lacking. Its not all bad, but there were some roasters who were’nt quite as funny as they tried to be. I still cant be mean and say they should stop, but they definitely didnt make me laugh (and I laugh at most jokes, whether it be dry wit or slapstick) but some of these seemed like the guy that makes bad jokes at parties (ya, sorry, im referencing a Dane Cook joke… fer shame).

Sorry, im not tryin to bash yer video. Anyways, the necro critic bonus video I will agree was rather missing the point however due to the fact that its under a roast video I suspect that was the idea (I looked at it more like bad satire). So technically the people bashing it are the joke here as they didnt get the satire. If im not a fool, and that is the case, then I’d say the video did its job and I thought it was done well (all be it pretentious maybe).

Anyway, Ive been around since Spoony’s Alone in the Dark Review which he posted on Gamespot. I had just written a review about it and found his video there and thgought it was rather clever, and I commented as such. Then I got bored and found his site and watched his videos, now I check his site everyday to see if a new video is up. Spoony is funny, and deserves the recognition and roasting of Fans and envious others. I wish him continued success, what little the internet provides. At least he will be famous in the small, off the internet, kind of way.

I still want to see a rebuttal from Spoony though. A roast is not done without a rebuttal.
=)

I really enjoy it when spoony does the doll shows, I think they’re hilarious. I actually wish he did more of them.

I really enjoy it when spoony does the doll shows, I think they’re hilarious. I actually wish he did more of them.

Also, I think the Space Mountain joke was meant to be a riff on “The hammer is my penis” from Dr. Horrible’s Sing-a-Long Blog.

The tribute is a hoot, even if its a bit awkward! But we’re all a little awkward, all of us. I know I am…

I first found the Spoony Experiment when Yahtzee recommended Spoony’s “The Thing” video on a Gamespot interview, and its been love and laughs ever since. The FMV Hell stuff is golden, seeing that part of gaming history through the eyes of Snark, and your old-school gaming reviews make me pine for the old days while remembering how damn silly they were. You make us laugh and make us think. Keep it up, Spoons!!

Was a great roast to watch. As a fan of Spoony’s I appretiate the opportunity to see other reivewers, or people in the same medium as he, take on where he came from and where he’s at.

One thing I’d like to request if possible (and forgive me if it already has) is that someone toss together a set of links to see more by the individual personalities in the video. I tried to use google to find something on a couple and I don’t know if I’m just not using the right keywords, or what when trying to find their work to broaden my internet watching habits.

Great work to those who made the video, and hope to see Spoony continue the reviews till he’s old and grey lol.

And last random thought: seeing lots of references to the KotDT stuff you did Spoony, but no list of issues etc in the faq or anything. Any chance of getting one to reference for back issues (loved KotDT when I worked at a hobby store and got to read it, fell outta the habit)? I’d look into trying to order them or something to see more of where you came from etc (or if anyone perusing the comments is able to answer that)

I gotta be honest, I liked the laundromat jokes! and the rats ass joke XD some jokes are bad on purpose, you can notice it in his tone of voice.

But space mountain… oh man, that was REALLY bad.

Bennett The Sage, Helldragon, and DeanTheAdequate all killed. :D Great writing guys! This was good fun, and a great idea.

Cheers to Noah! I haven’t been here for all 3 years (just discovered TSE 5 months ago), but I will be here supporting Spoony as long as he continues.

@”Necro Critic”:
#68 actually made my point for me. I really had a fun time watching your video because of the cutely pathetic way you try to act “creepy”. I mean when the video started, I was like “Erm… am I supposed to find this “emo” or “weird”? I don’t know, if anything, it’s annoying.” But when you ACTUALLY said “and here I was thinking *I* was creepy” that just cracked me up! (Insert Spoony’s patronizing “No, honey, no…” from A.O.I.T.D.-review here).
Tiny Tim is creepy! Tim Burton is creepy! Salad Fingers is creepy! Watch those guys and maybe one day you’ll get it right.

@Roasters:
I never really understood the concept and appeal of “roasting”, maybe it’s an american thing. ;)
I watched the Bob Saget Roast on youtube and it was kinda funny but that’s mainly because the man is such an awesomly sick bastard himself (and we all love him for it ^^)! Still I have to give you credit for planning, recording and editing a whole 60 minute video out of all those little parts and bits and pieces (which can be a pain in the ass, I know…) and even making it entertaining. As I say, I don’t really understand the concept of roasting. As far as I can tell it seems to be about insulting a person as hard and personally as possible by showing all his failures in public. Regarding that, I must say the tone was not as harsh as I would have expected but seeing that none of you actually “know” the roasted one (I mean, personally) you worked pretty well with what you had. At least you hardly fell into the trap of saying something like: “I hate him because he sucks, because … he’s stupid and … boring because … he sucks!” (Which I like to call the Irate-syndrome).

So Congratulations for pulling this together, GZ experiment for you 3rd anniversary, Necrocritic – I planned to do a “necrotic testicles dropping”-joke here but I won’t because that would be beneath me. I just envy your front-page-status, that’s all ^^

Good night, everybody!

The laundry joke was supposed to be bad, and for that it was funny, same as the Space Mountain = Penis one. Also, Necro, bro, that whole “it hurt my soul” “make your soul explode” “ROFL SOL” shit wasn’t funny or clever or anything not obnoxious in high school at the goth table during lunch (where it was said more often than the word “the”), and it sure as hell ain’t workin’ now.

Besides that though, Spoony, you’re the best man, as NC said in the end, never change.

At the top 10 worst jokes, if Spoony’s puns in SWAT 4 made it, surely his series of tree puns in Dragon Strike more than make the list? I personally found most of the jokes on that list pretty great, but if Mr. Emotion doesn’t like the three-ish SWAT 4 jokes, the 18-36 tree puns in Dragon Strike should make the list, right?

I don’t think Necro got the “blackout” joke. Did it have anything to do with the Sopranos at all? It was just about how the game’s level ended suddenly and unceremoniously

Necro doesn’t seem creepy. He looks and talks like a hippie.

Griff Morivan – Very funny, great job

DeanTheAdequate – Also very good

DarkChiron – ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

Overactor – Pretty bad

PushingUpRoses – Horrible

Covenant – Music is way too fucking loud, I could barely hear him.

Bennett The Sage – Great job

Helldragon – Pretty good

I see what everyone was trying to do here and it was a good idea in theory. But put into practice, it just falls flat. I mean, for the most part, these videos were just painful to watch. Correct me if I’m wrong, but aren’t these things supposed to be funny? I don’t think I found myself laughing at all. I don’t want to come off as one of those “OMGZ! YOU’RE MAKING FUN OF NOAH!” users, because I have no problem with roasts. When they’re done well. This wasn’t.

Here’s to you Spoony, I may have only been with you for the past year but here’s to many more.

Necro Critic sucked. He reads his lines at a bad pace, totally void of any rhythm, like he’s some child reading a textbook passage. And the shades don’t hide that at all. And half the jokes he said were bad, were tongue-in-cheek meant to be bad. The only real bad one there was the Spunky Brewster one, that joke was just weird. And it was pretty hypocritical of him, cuz most of his jokes were bad or intended to be bad, but none of them were good for it, partially due to that hypocrisy.

Haven’t watched the roast yet.

Congrats man, Congrats. And the cool thing is that yesterday was me and my GFs annniversary was yesterday.

Oh and before I throw everyone together in the same boat, Griff and Bennett did really good jobs. Have to agree with that.

Oh and before I throw everyone together in the same boat, Griff and Bennett did really good jobs. Have to agree with that.

I watch the Necro Critic’s top 10 first, and I gotta say he has no sense of humour whatsoever. All of those jokes were hilarious. He claims to love it yet he bashes his work.
Also, Necro Critic about Number 2?

That wasn’t bad, you are just stupid.

Also, is he blind or something? With the glasses?

oh yeah, he said the word “soul”, way too much. His look is weird too.

Awwww man! I loved Necro Critic! Haha!

Does the Necro critic have a teleprompter that only displays one word at a time or something? He was reading his lines as though there was a full stop after every word! That… is… the… worst… video… I… have… ever… seen. Did this guy have a stroke or something? Is that why he’s wearing those glasses? Is there a new strain of weed so strong it literally melts your brain whilst instead of giving you the munchies makes you want to do reviews? What’s going on here? Seriously, you can’t just memorize your lines or improvise them or something? You have to stick up a piece of paper with them on, then struggle to read it? As for SWAT 4 appearing on the list – those jokes were INTENTIONALLY bad, hence the sarcastic laughter that came straight after them. Have you not heard of this? Jokes which are so bad, they become funny because of how awful they are? I just can’t believe something this bad was featured on the site. WAY worse than the Spoony Bum.

good god i hope we dont see anymore of that necro critic. he’s like linkara without the funny.

i love all your jokes. even if some are bad it gives me a “HA” kind of laugh anyway.

oh. one more thing. i dont care what you guys say to me i freaking loved the spoony bum. made me sad seeing him holding the camera all : (

I think many of you missed the point entirely. Like… entirely.
I enjoyed the roast, however. Great job guys
<3 Biscuit.

Necro, you are anti-funny. If you were doing that on purpose as a joke you failed even more than if that’s your normal persona. Just please stop.

Methinks the Necro-critic sounds like his balls can’t make up their mind about whether or not to finally drop… It’s almost like they’re turtle-heading in and out of his abdomen… It’s as if his falsetto randomly seizes control of all higher motor functions! Although in his defense (or at least to agree with him) the snakes joke was pretty… yeah… But it still made me giggle.

Is it me or does the NecroCritic look/sound like a combination of Bill Lumbergh from Office Space and the Church Lady from Saturday Night Live?

promised myself i wouldn’t insult necro critic but at the end his failure to successfully drink without cringing and looking disgusted made me laugh so hard at the awful involved. still it takes balls to make such a video so i suppose my hat *must* go off to him.

Roasters were all pretty good, with Bennett and Griff winning out as the best

Man I thought I was the only one who yelled “PHANTASMAGORIA” all the time.

I hate people saying that the Dirty Harry review is a spoof on the Sopranos. If people would pay attention they would see that the game ended suddenly and that Spoony is making fun of that. Stop comparing the two! Gawd!

way to go Spoony. Here’s to three years of amazing talent. I joined the ride about a year ago when i was looking for sewer shark footage on youtube and stumbled upon your review. I laughed my ass off and was instantly addicted.

keep it up man, you and all the critics and reviewers are the friends i wish i had in high school.

I have learned two things from these new videos:

1. ”The Necro Critic” looks like the Crypt Keeper

2. These forums are full of unattractive, strange looking individuals…

Congrats Spoony!! I’ve only been watching your videos for a short time, but i am completely addicted. You are one of the funniest people out there man, and i hope your around for a long time to come!

god damn it, this roast shows more than necessary why Noah is the one getting roasted…

Fantastic job to everyone who contributed, let’s hope we get another awesome 3 years.

Pretty unbearable stuff.

Reaffirms why Spoony is the one with the popular website and anyone caring what he has to say and not any of these people.

The roast was unfunny Roasts are generally unfunny.

The Necro Critic – oh my.
If I would have to make a list of the top 10 unfunniest moments ever to be featured at the Spoony Experiment, it would consist solely of clips from his video.
First, he looks like a colorblind hippie. His acting is, well, how do I describe this?
This will do it: Watch “Top 11 Anime Villains” from ThatDudeInTheSuede

http://www.thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/ir/thatdudeinthesuede/animenia/1884-top-11-anime-villains

The “Necro Critic”-concept is this performance done a lot less entertaining. I don’t even have to compare them – just watch the video.

As for the joke:
I agree, the “Mormon Prom”-one was bad.
But the “Super Wing Commander”-one as an honorable mention? I don’t even think that one was a joke, that was just being condescending towards the game.
Also, why is everyone bashing the Spoony-Bum? It’s not the greatest joke I have ever seen in my like (OHMYGOD) but what’s there to hate about him? Can someone explain? Is the Necro Critic (Nostalgia Critic, Necro Critic, can anyone else see a pattern here?) just bashing on it because many people seem to do, even after Spoony himself did it, even using the clip from Spoony where he bashed the idea himself, shortly after he did it? You know, jumping on the bandwagon =/= funny.

The blackout a Sopranos-parody??? That’s the way the first level ends how can you not get that? How about some thinking before you put in on a Bottom 10 list? To quote the Nostalgia Critic: “Use your thoughts writers, use your thoughts.”

Space-mountain? Intentionally bad, anyone? Or as #104 points out a possible reference to Dr. Horrible’s Sing-a-Long Blog.

The lation singing bashing FF8? Not award-worthy, but bad? So bad that it had to be put in the video so that the world would learn “This soul-punchingly bad joke instantiates such soul-punching badness it will soulpunch you in the soul”? By the way, “soul” isn’t as funny as the Cinema Snob thinks “Yeti” is. Saying it all the time does not guarantee you’re funny.

The toys in “Hell’s Kitchen”? “Jump” in “Make My Video”, the snakes in “Samurai Zombie Nation”, the puns in “SWAT 4″ and “Final Fantasy”?? “That thing you do”?!? I won’t even comment on those. It’s so frustrating that it’s just not worth it.

But hey, I can accept it that there are pretentious people on the internet who review reviewers (Am I reviewing a review of reviews?). Unfortunately, that’s not everything.
No, the Necro Critic actually had the balls to STEAL FROM THE NOSTALGIA CRITIC’S REVIEW OF “NORTH”!!!

Did that guy seriously think no one would notice that the joke is copied 1:1 from Doug?
That was even more painful as “The defense rests.” Seriously, right now that totally cracks me up after having watched the Necro Critic. He makes “North” look funny. At least “North” has “so bad it’s good”-moments not many however) and it will give you flashbacks to Doug’s review (to borrow from Spoony, it’s like watching Manos without the MST3K commentary, you can still imagine it’s there).

So please watch “North” and as an epic climax of suck WATCH YOUR OWN VIDEOS when you want to see some bad jokes. The only positive thing I got from this review was that it reminded me to randomly yell “PHANTASMAGORIA!!” in public.

Oh, and of course happy “birthday” Spoony.

@ Biscuit-

Yeah, people definitely missed the point. However this is the internet, and haters are bound to surface. The important thing is that Spoony realizes that this was done out of appreciation, and no one can touch that no matter how wretched we may or may not have been. And I think he does appreciate it, so it’s all good.

Yeah, whether you liked it or not aside, I just hope everyone gets the point of what a roast is. Some of you do get it, and you are right that the roastee gets to zing everyone at the end, which I really hope Spoony follows through with.

What’s not to get? It’s a roast – it’s making fun of the roastee but ultimately out of appreciation of what they do and have done in a humorous way that is entertaining and oftentimes borderline distasteful.

This wasn’t funny.

Or entertaining.

First of all, happy anniversary!

I will admit that I’m from Germany and hadn’t hear of roasts before I watched that one “The Office” episode, but it looked fun there. So I’m probably not the best person to tell anyone if this was good. But I had to turn off the video in the middle of PushingUpRoses’ (?, the one with the drawings) part, simply because I didn’t like anyone but the first guy and the one doing the transitions; I was just feeling embarrassed for everybody else. The timing of the jokes was pretty off and often because of that, it was neither funny on a ‘bashing’ level nor on any other. And you were pretty tame, too, at least the first ones that I could get through. (Then again, I wouldn’t know how to bash the Spoonster properly, either.)

But I guess humor is subjective, and it’s the thought that counts. So good work.

*And before I get called out for not understanding what a roast is, I simply can’t find any other good word to describe what I mean instead of ‘bashing’ (due to dictionary and brain fail). I understood that a roast is not really about honestly bashing someone, but more what HaloOf The Sun described.

Hey guys have you noticed people on the internet can’t read!?!?!
( had to I’m sorry)
Great work guys. Thanks but I rather not have to look a DarkChiron ever again IN MY LIFE please k thx!

Congratulations on the 3 years!

I didn’t half-mind the roast, but the Necro Critic scared me. His “humor” was stale and he just seemed to be nitpicking.

Happy Anniversary, Spoony!

I didn’t watch the Roast yet, but yeah, without a rebuttal, I have a feeling it’s not going to be merely as enjoyable as other Roasts I’ve seen. Sorry, but that’s kind of the point of a roast, y’know?

Also, NecroCritic is really, really monotone and boring. Given his name (before now I never even heard of him), I have a feeling the deadpan nature is suppose to be his act. If so, then I’ll know not to watch any of his reviews. But if not, seriously, the guy sounds like he could lighten up. Smoke a bold, relax, get laid. You think the Sopranos joke is old in the Dirty Harry review, Necro? The deadpan monotone gag was funny when BEN STEIN did it.

Though, despite how obviously bored and unrivoting NecroCritic is, he… does raise a few points. But it’s that humor that draws me onto Spoony ANYWAY. Keep it up, Spoony! Let’s give them another 3 years!

Been with ya since “Knights”, Spoony, and left the mag when you left! Will also leave the internet if you should go down! Glory to the experiment! Let the snarkness consume us all!

I don’t see the problem with the Space Mountain joke. It’s supposed to make you feel uncomfortable and seem out of place because it is.

I’m always willing to give new and upcoming critic’s the benefit of the doubt and more than usually, they’ll get better. However, Necro has not done all that much to improve any of the problems on his show. His voice is like nails on a chalkboard and his jokes are pretty awful. This list is a complete joke. Some of Spoony’s best material. “Shittier than a Mormon prom” made me laugh hysterically.

I don’t see the problem with the Space Mountain joke. It’s supposed to make you feel uncomfortable and seem out of place because it is.

I’m always willing to give new and upcoming critic’s the benefit of the doubt and more than usually, they’ll get better. However, Necro has not done all that much to improve any of the problems on his show. His voice is like nails on a chalkboard and his jokes are pretty awful. This list is a complete joke. Some of Spoony’s best material. “Shittier than a Mormon prom” made me laugh hysterically.

Also, the Space Mountain joke. Uh… Rick Flair, anyone? He even does the WOOOOO part. Or Rick Flair took that from something else… but I always knew what Space Mountain was. But yeah, that’s still a pretty bad joke. But once again, it’s why I like him.

Am I the only one who thinks that the ‘roast’ was one gigantic mindfuck? I tried to watch the video, but I really didn’t know what the hell was going on. It’s just a plethora of random video clips from Spoony, with some people who are apparently roasting him, maybe it’s because I’m hungover, but I didn’t know what the fuck was going on!

Also, I don’t think the Necro Critic is that bad, that Irate Gamer joke was funny. However his top ten……not so much. Especially considering the fact that I thought that all of Spoony’s ‘worst jokes’ were actually funny. The ones that were ‘bad’ were KNOWINGLY bad. That’s what made the joke ten times more awesome.

And I really hate the way the Necro Critic looks, what the hell is that? Is that some sort of gimmick? He looks like some sort of blind chick that works at the library or something.

It’s just bothersome.

Yes, I’m well aware of the fact that most of the jokes on the list were intentionally bad. THAT WAS THE FREAKING POINT!!!

Dear Angry Internet People,

If you don’t like the videos there is no need to bash all the people who worked hard on them and put them out here for your FREE enjoyment. If you know so much about comedy and making videos then please, quit bitching and make your own videos. I am guessing most of you don’t even have the courage to make a video with yourself featured in it like these people (who I am proud to call my friends) in the two videos did.

Dear Angry Internet People,

If you don’t like the videos there is no need to bash all the people who worked hard on them and put them out here for your FREE enjoyment. If you know so much about comedy and making videos then please, quit bitching and make your own videos. I am guessing most of you don’t even have the courage to make a video with yourself featured in it like these people (who I am proud to call my friends) in the two videos did.

hey spoony…i am Still waiting for that next “SWAT 4″ video..anytime now!!!

Helldragon! What a twist! Now if only NTom64 could join in…

@DaMegaFish

Actually what you’re suggesting (about the people who found the videos… let’s say, less than good… not having the courage to make their own) kind of works against you. I’m sure most of us are well aware that we could not make an entertaining video, which is why we don’t. That doesn’t mean we can’t recognize something that isn’t funny when we see it.

Kudos to all of you for trying. Don’t try again.

This was great!

@Halo

Except some people to enjoy the videos so really you lack any real point. You try to say that you and the other people recognize stuff that isn’t funny but your ability to speak for all was broke just a little while ago by Danny who thought it was great. I don’t care if you like it or don’t however. The main thing I don’t agree with on the bashings is just that, the bashings. If you don’t like it you can say you didn’t like it sure, but when you start attacking the people in the videos and their efforts THAT is the point where the problems start with me. Sucks you didn’t like it though; quit bitching and move on.

I never said I speak for everyone. Obviously there are some people that like it. Your desperate attempt at putting a different meaning on to my post is childish.

It’s also childish to assume that when you put something out in public that you created, whether it be a video, a piece of music, a drawing, etc. that no one will tell you what they honestly think. And it’s honestly a lame attempt at comedy. It’s an opinion, people have them, grow up.

Perhaps you’re the one that needs to move on, considering it appears this is making you so angry.

Mega-

I don’t think people realize how whiny and ridiculous people sound when they bash things so severely. And to be honest, this was posted on the forums, initially, not here on the home page. Which means Spoony put it here. If he didn’t like it/appreciate it, reguardless of quality, it wouldn’t be here. And thats all that matters, everyone else who wants to indirectly judge Spoonys fans, and HIS judgement for putting it up here, don’t actually matter, and are obviously not apart of the TSE community like the forums, which are much more tight knit and enjoyable.

The video wasn’t outstanding by any means, but it is enjoyable to see people show appreciation for such a great guy.

All humanity has lost credibility in these comments. I’m extremely shocked that any of you even have internet. Honestly, you don’t even deserve it. I also call the people who made the video’s, friends. I think they did an awesome job, and Spoony OBVIOUSLY thinks they did an awesome job or he wouldn’t have featured any of it. And what matters is that HE enjoyed them. It’s a good thing he’s not an asshole like the people in these comments are. (of course excluding those that did enjoy the video’s). I’m just beside myself that so many assholes could exist in one spot.

Also, to those bitching about how a roast SHOULD go, with the Roastee being in the video’s. I was told that this was a surprise, and Spoony didn’t know anything about it.

You guys are terrible, terrible wastes of human air.
*shakes head*

Halo-

You keep saying that it was a bad attempt as if it is a matter of a fact. This makes you a moron because there are people who do like it as we have already pointed out. And for you telling them to not try again? Why not? Ooh thats right, because your opinion about everything is perfect and spot on.

In all seriousness, you have nothing to complain about. You didn’t pay to see the video, you could have turned it off at any time (which I am almost sure you did if you didn’t like it.) So whats your point again? You don’t see me trolling on people I don’t like so I am just surprised that everyone here feels the need to troll on the people in these videos.

Congrats spoony, you’re really one of my favorite online people i’ve ever followed. you never get stale no matter how many times i’ve watched your videos and you give me hope in humanity with your reviews on movies haha.

here’s to many more years of laughs and entertainment :D

Pretty funny all around. Even Necro wasn’t too bad though I’m certainly not impressed enough to watch his stuff. Esspecailly since some of the jokes he mentioned were bad intentionally.

Plus you have to smoke some hard crack to think FF9 was worse then FF8. FF9 actautlly had merits and likible characters.