The Spoony Experiment

Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith

View Comments

Starship Troopers

A Review by Noah Antwiler

I'm the only one left. Before, I had a group of friends eager to go with me. They skipped work and school, and even cleared out their schedule to go several times that day. That never happened. Disappointed, disheartened, disillusioned, they drove home. Some were angry, as I was. Some were in denial, citing unrealistic expectations and overly-critical audiences. And the rest shrug and respond with the blasé summary, "It was okay." The second movie had promise; we were finally getting to an actual war. The action was ramping up. The stakes were higher. We were finally getting to the wars of Star Wars. The group who went with me was about a quarter of its previous size, and we went wearing grimaces of poor expectations, like one anticipating the removal of wisdom teeth. Already jaded, we watched in a mournful silence the one-dimensional utility-only dialogue, the pervasive and invasive special effects, the ruination of established characters, and some of the worst acting known in science fiction since Johnny Mnemonic. Some were devastated once again. Some weren't surprised. Some remained in denial. And others conceded, "It was better than the first. It was okay."

If only he'd given us some catharsis.

Now it's only me. I'm it. My own brother-- who will watch anything-- refused to go. My other friends have patently declined to ever pay to see the movie. It's not out of any protest or organized boycott; I think you can see the futility in such a gesture. George Lucas has so much money I like to imagine he has a Money Bank like Scrooge McDuck, doing the backstroke through $100 bills he earned from the sales of action figures alone. It's not a protest, it's not a mark of honor to refuse. It's not a rallying call or some martyring "I am Spartacus" cry. It's just...over for them. They're DONE. They just can't take it any more. They're not even able to steel themselves to ride out this crummy trilogy as it crashes down in flames, like they said they would at first. Their hearts are broken, and apathy beats disappointment. Episode 3 could be the best movie ever, and I could even tell them that. And you know what? They STILL wouldn't go. That's how ruined the series is. That's how ruined BOTH series are. You can't even go watch the original trilogy anymore, not without being forced to pay for those damnable special editions. The editions that splice Jabba the Hutt crudely into Episode 4, and where Greedo still manages to get his shot off first. The editions that change Boba Fett's voice to some Kiwi motherfucker's instead of the cold, mercenary voice we fell in love with. The editions that dropkick the old Anakin Skywalker out of the film and replace his ghostly apparition with the most unwelcome Hayden Christensen.

These are the editions that will endure into the future. These terrible, altered movies will be the only way they'll be preserved, unless you're one of the few that managed to salvage the untouched movies on VHS tape. Not only has George Lucas ruined the new movies, he's managed to go back and kill what love we've had for the old ones. Can the man not stand back and just let his artistry endure as it is? Must he give in to weakness and continually retouch his work in some Sisyphusian attempt to perfect it? Why does he not realize that he's doing harm, not good?

I barely thought it possible, but he managed to rape us with a camera that big.

My bitching is, for the most part, falling on deaf ears. The movie will still make a zillion dollars, which most will equate with the creation of a successful film. This just isn't true, as the Star Wars name has a certain built-in fanbase to it. You could make a tape of George Lucas receiving a golden shower while sodomizing himself with a prop lightsaber, call it Star Wars: Fuck the Fans, and it would still make $60 million in the opening weekend. Good or bad, kids will want to go, older fans will be delusional enough to wander in, and critics like me will pay just to watch the train wreck and gripe about it afterwards.

I walked into the theater already very pissed off at Star Wars. I wasn't fuming at the prequels, or psyching myself up to go into the movie with a bad attitude. On the contrary, my initial impressions were that Episode 3 would prove to be quite good. I was pissed off because C-3PO was on my box of Cheez-Its. Yoda was trying to take my Mountain Dew. Darth Vader was having a staring contest with the fucking Burger King, and shilling Sith M&Ms on the side. R2-D2's on my Pepsi. I'm drinking out of R2-D2's head. I can't turn around without seeing Star Wars plastered on anything and everything edible, on all 3 major gaming platforms and wired on XBox Live. I haven't seen promotional madness like this since Batman hit theatres. And there has never been a series of movies so toyetic as the Star Wars prequels. Hey, there's nothing wrong with being capitalistic. But doesn't it drive you nuts to think the only real reason there's a Droid Army, a General Grievous, Wookiees and Jedi starfighters around is so we can market them as action figures? Am I really so cynical as to see cold marketing figures in every creative decision made in these movies now?

I guess so. I don't like being this angry at the movies. No, honestly, I really don't. And just to prove it, I'll say this up front: Revenge of the Sith is, in fact, the best of the 3 prequels. That's a damn low bar, and it doesn't say much, so I'll even go further than that. I was even entertained by this movie. Was it a good movie? Definitely not. But for the first time in a LONG time, its heart was in the right place. The action was ratcheted up, there was actual tension, there was a war going on, and the stakes were high. The action sequences are undeniably awesome, and some scenes will endear themselves as classics among the fans, even myself. From a purely shallow standpoint, I can easily lean back, drool into my popcorn, and watch the laser sword fighting like a good boy and be entertained by all the kung-fu and flashing lights. But there's nothing to it here. It's all flash and flair, all CG and robots and toys, and blue screens. There's no depth here. The dialogue is ham-fisted and brutish, the plot unsurprising and is only a clothesline to string together protected battle sequences, and the acting is still truly horrible. Stifled by Lucas' inept direction, the only drama found here is in the climactic final duel, when the actors finally, FINALLY, break out of their shells. Production values can buy kickass action sequences (and they have), but they can't buy drama.

The theater was about 70% full. Most were smart enough to avoid the front seven rows and subsequently avoided the massive chiropractic nightmare that would have certainly ensued. Despite the PG-13 warning (oooooh scary!) and the rumors of intense violence, there's not a parent around dissuaded from bringing their brats along. And so the majority of the audience was costumed dorks and those without costumes with their kids. Those in costume did not have kids, because people who dress like Tusken Raiders do not get laid.

Why is it always ugly dudes who show up when I'm there?

I was seated at the end of the row in a nice spot in the theater with a row of 4 year-olds as far to my left as I could see. Consequently, I could never settle down to watch a damn minute of the film in peace, because I was being constantly interrupted by middle-aged morons brushing their asses in my face as they escorted their kids to the bathroom. And as soon as they got back, their second kid decided that he needed to piss, too. And so the journey of parenting enters its vicious cycle, demonstrating that kids have a bladder capacity the size of a shotglass, drink sodas twice the size of their heads, and consequently manage to hold their pee for approximately 4 minutes. Revenge of the Sith is about two and a half hours long, so you have to figure most kids have to tinkle...what, two, three times? There were a dozen of them in my row, so my movie going experience was of a science-fiction film intercut with more ass than a frat initiation. GOD I hate movie audiences. I hate kids.

Time to answer the burning question. You know which one. Does the Gungan bite the dust? Is it slow? Is it painful? Is it messy and deliciously drawn out over the entire movie while a psychotic dentist keeps asking "Is it safe?"

Wishful thinking.

Nope. Jar Jar's screen time is reduced to a net total of 4 seconds-- which in itself is a blessing, but definitely not the payoff fans worldwide were screaming for. It just seems strange that his character is virtually ignored given his significance in the last two films. I can't believe I'm complaining about it, but what can I say? I wanted the floppy bastard to suffer. Badly.

I like the cat's expression most of all.

The opening crawl of the movie is finally exciting! "War!" it says as the first word! War! HUNH! Good God y'all! What is it good for? I have to admit, the crawl is awesome this time around, with phrases like "Evil is everywhere" all over it. Evidently, the Droid Army is kicking tail around the galaxy, and their military genius, General Grievous, has abducted Chancellor Palpatine. His last name is Grievous. Oddly, his first name is Dave. Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin "Little Orphan Annie" Skywalker are chosen to board Dave Grievous' star cruiser, kick ass, and save the Chancellor. The Republic stages an attack on the fleet to cover the Jedi insertion, and so the movie's first scene pans down on a cataclysmic space battle full of CG that costs more than I'd make in a thousand years. It's at this point that Playstation controllers sprung from the back of everyone's seats and we got to collectively control the video game ahead of us.

The droids deploy an impressive array of obstacles and enemies to bar the Jedis' progress, including robot spaceships, tracking missiles, and little teeny cute robots called "Buzz-droids" that latch onto Obi-Wan's starfighter and start tearing it up with their cutesy wutsey wittle claws. Obi-Wan's all "Oh snap!" and starts freaking out because he can't get rid of the droids all over his ride. But Anakain's all "Chill cuz", and starts shooting Obi-Wan's ship like an idiot. Obi's a little pissed off that Anakin's still pretty stupid after all these years of mentoring, and angrily tells Anakin to do something else. Here's a tip, Jedi Master Jackass, USE THE FORCE to rip the little bastards off your ship. Anyway, Anakin finally grinds his wing against the other ship, scraping the droids off. Obi-Wan makes a mental node to charge Anakin for this shit when he calls Maaco. "Best star pilot in the galaxy" my ass, Ben!

The Jedi make a crash landing on the hangar bay of Grievous' flagship, ninja leap out of their cockpits, and start chopping the crap out of everything that beeps and moves. The talking battle droids that need binoculars to see are even more annoying than they were before, because they groan in agony, say stupid things, and even develop sassy attitudes (One in particular delivers something to an ungrateful Grievous and quips with a catty "You're welcome").

Check it out, Anakin's Schwartz is bigger than Lonestar's.

"I sense Count Dooku!" Anakin declares. I sense a stupid damn name for a villain. R2-D2 follows along and gets relegated to hotwiring all the electronics and elevators that the Jedi need. The two Jedi start charging down the corridors, cleaving their way to the elevators, and eventually bumble directly into an ambush, where a half-dozen droids have them dead-to-rights at gunpoint. Incredibly, instead of shooting them dead where they stand, the droids stand there dumbly while the Jedi spin around and decapitate the lot of them. What the hell just happened? You're telling me that droids missed the opportunity to just waste them? I really can't take this. This is the fearsome threat that has the Republic on the defensive?

I am Wookiee Wallace! Freedom!

R2 has to work overtime to keep the Jedi in safety, by opening doors and operating lifts, and in a silly breach of continuity, the little astromech droid moves faster and more smoothly than he ever did before (he's entirely CG). Two large droids come to investigate all the racket that R2 and his communicator are making, forcing R2 to hide amidst some crates. The droids, despite the insane noise that R2 was making, eventually shrug and decide it's not worth their effort to investigate the cacophony on the other side of the flight deck. What, are you kidding me? The DROIDS-- the programmed killing machines-- hear a noise, look over, decide it's nothing, say "Ah forget about it" and go about their business? Get bent, George. Eventually, however, the droids get wise to R2 when he's flushed from cover, and attack him. R2 poops a spray of oil all over the attacking droids, deploys his leg rockets, and sets the oil ablaze, immolating the two droids into a melted heap of slag. I'm warning you, movie, you're already pissing me off. Don't make me flip you off.

The Jedi finally reach the chamber where Palpatine is being held, and are immediately confronted by Saruman the Sith. "You won't get away this time, Dooku!" Kenobi declares. I really don't mean to harp on about this whole "Dooku' thing, but it really undermines anything heroic or badass you might want to say when you tack on the rather undignified word 'Dooku' on the end of the sentence.

"I'm here to chew bubblegum and kick ass, Dooku!"

"Dooku....Dooku...come out and playyyyy-haaayyyyyy!"

"My name is Neo, Dooku."

"Remember when I said I'd kill you last, Dooku? I LIED."

Considering how badly they got their asses handed to them the last time, Anakin and Kenobi decide (rather unfairly, in my opinion) to double-team Dooky. But Count Douchebag is up to the task, and handily outduels the two cheating Jedi. He Force-shoves Kenobi kidneys-first into a steel rail, and pins him to the floor beneath some heavy machinery. Obi-Wan's down for the count, leaving Anakin to duel Little Deuce Coupe alone. God help us. But surprisingly, it looks like Annie's picked up some new moves since his days as a total pussy, and manages to (literally) disarm DooDoo. Palpatine gruffly orders Anakin to waste Dookie Howser where he stands, but Anakin waffles on the issue. He seems to remember reading "decapitating a completely helpless opponent who has yielded is wrong" somewhere in the front half of the Jedi Handbook. But the chancellor is insistent, so Anakin essentially shrugs and lops Count Dookula's head off. Very strange scene going on here.

Palpatine: KILL HIM!!

Anakin: *whines* But...but...isn't that wrong?

Palpatine: Shut yer cake-hole! Waste his ass!

Anakin: Okay. *SHLORCK*

When the chancellor orders Anakin to kill him, Dooku gives Palpatine a priceless "Hey, what the fuck!" look over to the camera and is halfway through shouting "I thought we was homies, you asshole!" when Anakin offs him. Interestingly, Dooku does not explode in a rush of dark side energies like every other Sith lord I've seen. Continuity! Paging continuity, please report to the script. I caught you napping, George! Can't slip anything past me.

Anakin goes over to check on Obi-Wan. Palpatine tells him not to bother, but Anakin drones out woodenly "His fate will be the same as ours." Man, this dialogue sucks bantha balls. Obi-Wan finally wakes up after a while, and acts like a dope about what happened, and seems surprisingly lucid for a guy who was knocked cold, and probably should have a broken hip, ribs, and should be pissing blood from the beating he took. Not to mention that anyone who's been beaten into unconsciousness is likely to be in serious medical peril, and needs help immediately. He would certainly be in no condition to resume the escape as if he'd never been hurt. Meanwhile, the ship is taking quite a beating from the battle outside, and it starts falling towards the planet, twisting and tumbling awkwardly about its axes. The group starts slipping and falling as the ship twists around, even clinging tenuously to a doorway as the hallway pitches down beneath them.

Get your physics straight, or the Snoop Dizzle will get on ya.

I don't really know why this happens. When did "down" become an absolute direction in space? They're not close enough to the planet for gravity to have its full influence on them, and if the ship had artificial gravity, "down" should always be relative to the floor, regardless of how the ship is oriented. So why, then, are they always falling downward relative to the planet?

General Grievous finally gets wise to the Jedi's presence, corrects the artificial gravity somehow, and captures all three in a "ray shield" along with R2-D2. Grievous looks whipped and is selling the effects of some off-camera beat-down (with Mace Windu, I'm told) by wheezing, coughing, and looking achy all over. I'm not really sure why a giant cyborg should be wheezing and out of breath, but hey, maybe he's not a very good cyborg.

Come to think of it, why do the droid ships have breathable atmospheres at all? They have no living crews, Grievous can live quite happily in the vacuum of space (as we later see), and accommodating a human prisoner is a rare-- nay, freak occurrence that wouldn't necessitate a full shipwide life support system with heat and air.

Grievous confronts them and takes away their lightsabers, gloating over his latest conquest. If he had a brain in his witless metal skull, he'd blast them dead on the spot. But unfortunately, he's afflicted with the ego common to all Bond villains and jawjacks with the heroes endlessly until they escape. On Anakin's signal, Artoo overloads himself and turns into a giant Roman candle or something, allowing the heroes the distraction to pull all of the collected lightsabers back towards themselves with the Force! Okay, I admit, that's pretty slick and is much more in the realm of believability when it comes to Artoo's capabilities as a droid (unlike the booster rockets). Grievous is, of course, stunned that the two JEDI KNIGHTS he's captured would do something so devious as to pull their weapons back with the Force. It's only...you know...THE ONE TRICK THEY'RE KNOWN FOR!!!

Stop whining!

Great Zarquon, Grievous is one dumb son of a bitch. He jumps out the window into space, latches onto the outside hull, jumps back into the ship, gets into an escape pod, and fires them all off at once, hoping that the Jedi will go down with the ship once it's destroyed by the Republic. The ship is getting thoroughly trashed by a sudden broadside attack from a Republic battleship, and starts to break up. Obi-Wan asks Anakin if he has any idea how to fly a Droid Army cruiser, and Anakin's all "Yeah asshole, they teach us that in our sophomore year." They decide to land the capital ship on the planet surface, like there's nothing stupid about that idea. Palpatine's battling back the urge to roll his eyes, because as rescue plans go, this one sucks. The cruiser screams through the atmosphere of the planet, breaks in half, and roars through the air downward, almost completely ablaze. Aerial firefighting ships spray the ship down with flame retardant (damn, they're fast, aren't they?), and Anakin has the incredible good fortune to crash land the ship on a conveniently barren flat strip of runway just wide and long enough to fit a humongous military ship. The odds boggle my mind.

Kenobi and Anakin are given a heroes welcome back on Coruscant for their daring rescue. Obi-Wan manages to bluff his way out of the festivities on the excuse he doesn't really dig the whole political scene, and he wants Anakin to revel in the glory he's earned. I like to think he's ditching Anakin's whiny ass so he can go back to the Jedi temple and impress all the hot Jedi chicks with the story. Screw Annie, he's thinking, he can get my sloppy seconds when I'm done with that hot Twi'lek bitch.

What? Just because Obi-Wan's a Jedi master he can't get tail? Let me tell you something, ladies, Kenobi will bring on the Force, if you know what I mean. They call him Big Ben. Yoda says that size matters not, but he ain't talked to the Obi-Ho Train. Oh yeah. You know it. Meanwhile, Anakin throws a party at the Jedi Temple to celebrate his victory. Now is the time on Star Wars when we dance.

Look at those action hips!

Actually, Anakin sneaks off to get some action with Padme. They're still trying to keep their relationship a secret, but Anakin's been away for a while and he's got the urge for a little Natalie Nookie. To his great surprise, Padme reveals that she's preggers, and Anakin looks like he's been slapped in the face with a trout. "This is the happiest moment in my life," he says in his best imitation of a 2x4. Excuse me.

LIAR!!! LIAR!!! LIAR!!!

I still wonder how Padme and Anakin have managed to keep their marriage a complete secret. This problem is compounded with the fact that Padme is quite obviously a pregnosaur. Wouldn't the press have a field day with this juicy little bit of gossip? Wouldn't there be someone reporting on one of the more controversial political figures in the Senate? Anakin and Padme basically live together, and nobody thinks that odd? Nobody's taking pictures of them? Obi-Wan's completely ignorant of this? They make out in public. I just wonder where the "fourth estate" is in all of this intrigue.

I know, I know, I'm thinking. Stop it.

Meanwhile, General Grievous is coordinating his attack plan with Darth Sidious over a holocom. A CG robot talking to a hologram. Do we even need actors anymore in this movie? Am I just watching a cartoon now?

Anakin is plagued by visions of Padme's death in his dreams, similar to the ones that occurred when he sensed that his mother was in danger. Even though Anakin emotes like a pile of lumber, Padme senses that something's wrong and questions him about it. I find it interesting that she sleeps in pearls with her hair permed and arranged perfectly. Must be cushy being a former queen voted out of office. The dialogue and acting are so bad in these romantic scenes, all I can do is mourn the fact that I won't ever get to see Natalie Portman's boobs from the movie Closer.

Mmm. And you know I would, baby. Denny Crane.

Anakin needs some indecipherable fortune cookie wisdom, so he consults Master Yoda on the matter. Of course, he can't blab about the fact he's nailing Padme froggy-style, because they'd kick him out of the Jedi order. So his approach is evasive and half-baked, sort of like when you're trying to question a doctor about a sexual dysfunction you think you might have, but you're trying to be coy about it. "Uh yeah, this friend of mine's been having this itching. Down there. And uh...my friend...says it burns when I pee-- HE pees. When my friend pees. And I think there's a rash. He showed me. My friend I mean. Not that we do that a lot...ever actually. I'm not gay." Anyway, Anakin's scared he's going to lose Padme.

"Fear of loss, a path to the Dark Side is!" Yoda intones gravely. What ISN'T a path to the Dark Side with you, Yoda? This whole Jedi thing sucks, man. You might not notice this, but Frank Oz's voice is wildly inconsistent when he does his Yoda voice between movies. It really sticks out for me.

Palpatine's been rather impressed with how weak-willed and witless Anakin is, combined with his ability to kill like an obedient dog when scolded, so he starts kissing up. He appoints Anakin his representative on the Jedi Council, an act which torques the other Jedi masters off to no end. None of them really like Anakin because he's porking Padme, and he's generally irritating. Anakin's fired up over the news, because if he sits on the Jedi Council, he gets promoted to the rank of master. Only Mace Windu's a jerk about it. He lets Anakin sit in on the meetings, but makes it crystal clear that to the rest of the council, Anakin's still a punkass n00b, not l33t j3d1 like Mace is. He refuses to promote him to master, like that's what you really want to do with the most powerful Jedi in the room with anger management problems that you DON'T want to fall to the Dark Side: alienate him from the rest of the Jedi, bitch slap him down socially in front of everyone, and make him immediately hostile towards everyone in authority. Brilliant move, Mace, you twit. Palpatine doesn't even need any help twisting this kid to the Dark Side if you're gonna be such a such an asshat about all this.

The dutchy on the left-hand side,
will you pass.

Anakin fumes in the corner, plotting bloody revenge on Mace while Yoda continues on with the war briefing. More than any other movie previously, something weird has happened to Yoda. Before, his speech patterns were quirky and endearing. He had this cute little way of switching around subjects and predicates every once in a while, and it made him sound wise and inscrutable. But the script took his normal speech and turned the knob up to 10 on the Insanity Factor. Now, every single sentence he utters is inverted. It's almost impossible to decipher what he's saying. "The outlying systems, they must sweep." "Go, I will." "Good relations with the wookiees, I have." It's ceased to be a personality quirk, and has actually become a pattern of speech that would take a conscious effort to maintain, and a lot of effort to mentally restructure sentences to fit the pattern. It's really infuriating how inconsistent the dialogue is.

After the council session, Anakin still can't believe what a dickhead Mace is. Obi-Wan tries to console him briefly, but pulls him aside to tell him of a secret mission appointed for him by the rest of the council. They want Anakin to spy on Chancellor Palpatine since they figure he's had complete control over the military for a decade or so, and he seems to have no intention of releasing the reins of power...well, there's a chance he miiiiiiiight be somewhat naughty. Never mind that such an action is treasonous and not the way Jedi are supposed to do things, they're asking Anakin to narc on his friend. Anakin protests, but Kenobi summarily tells him to be a good boy and do as he's told. Good doggy. It's been plainly obvious to me that the Jedi Council has been stagnant and corrupt from the first movie, and could do with a little genocide to clear the air, and Anakin's finally starting to get that message.

Mace, Yoda, and Kenobi take a ride on the bus together, and discuss Anakin's rather impulsive behavior. Not that I'd be one to side with Mr. Whiny, but you guys are humiliating him with your menial tasks, your disrespect, your cliquish rejection of him from your old boys' club, and the fact you never invite him to go golfing with the other Jedi masters. The guy's got feelings, you know. Mace has doubts that Anakin is Sith bait, but Kenobi naively spouts off his nonsense that Anakin's a part of the prophecy of immaculate conception that he will bring balance to the Force.

Ooooh! Now that's a scary team!

Okay guys, I know I've shouted about this before. But think about this. Just for a second. Count the number of Jedi in the galaxy. Good. Big number, yeah? Now count the number of Sith. One, maybe two? Now how do you balance this equation? One of two ways: decrease the number of Jedi, or increase the number of Sith. And guess what, NEITHER OPTION WORKS OUT TO YOUR BENEFIT!! COME ON, Jedi. You guys are supposed to be the wisest, most conscientious dudes in the galaxy. This is NOT that hard to figure out. Seriously Yoda, what is WRONG with you? As soon as Jake Lloyd walked into the council chamber, you should have leapt out of your beanbag chair, fired up your lightsaber, and chopped him into crinkle fries. I'm supposed to entrust the safety of the universe to a group of people this stupid? Where can I sign up for the Sith magazine?

As I said, Obi-Wan supports his apprentice a hundred percent. Yoda sighs and says "I hope right, you are." Please Yoda, I'm begging you, just shut up.

Meanwhile, Anakin goes home and argues with Padme in front of one of the most obvious blue screens in history.

Marvin?

Anakin runs off to see Palpie, who's taking in a show at the theatre. It's some really weird show, too, involving gigantic amorphous blobs of goo with lights floating around in side them while bad Kitaro music plays. It's all about as entertaining as watching a screen saver for an hour, and I have no idea who would pay to see such a thing when there's a live act at Jabba's palace that kicks all kinds of butt. Palpie goes for the soft touch by telling Anakin he thinks that the Jedi Council is corrupt (duh), and that they're really no different from the Sith, other than the Sith prefer dark clothes and badass nicknames. He relates a parable of a former Sith lord, Darth Plagueis, a man who could influence the midichlorians to create and restore life and to save the lives of others.

George, my friend, you've gone and said the bad word. The M-word. I thought we talked about this.

Anyway, that's all Anakin really needs to hear. Palpie relates the story to the Jedi's greed for power, just like everyone else's-- but Anakin's only interested in the "restoring life" part. He wants to learn that power to save Padme from her imminent death. Palpie seals the deal by telling him that it's nothing he can be taught from a Jedi. "And don't try Googling it," he says, "It's not listed." Palpatine tries to relate another story about the much less-successful Sith lord, Darth Herpes, but Anakin runs off to the Jedi Council before he can get started. It's probably better he didn't go into how Darth Herpes died, anyway.

For no reason whatsoever, the movie heads to the planet Kashyyyk, homeworld of the wookiees. Yoda lands with an army of clone troopers to combat the droids that have established a foothold in the area, and starts to prepare the local wookiees for war. Why are the droids here? Why do they feel the need to capture an arboreal planet full of 8-foot tall primitive monkeys. No offense to the wookiees, but I really don't think they've got much that can harm their intergalactic fleet, nor do they have anything worth capturing. In reality, all of this is a slim excuse to crowbar Chewbacca into the plot. For reasons beyond my comprehension, Chewie's good friends with Yoda because, as he says, "Good relations with the wookiees, I have." Good relations with the wookiees? Do you routinely go joyriding to backwater planets to make friends with furry savages who haven't discovered space travel yet? Knowing Yoda, maybe.

The wookiees work themselves into a frenzy, and soon enough, the droid army attacks! The clone troopers demonstrate their complete lack of ability to hit anything, but it's okay because the droid army appears to have severe myopia too. The wookiees fare better, and shout "It's clobberin' time" in Shyriiwook as they go whacking the droids with their clubs. The droids bring in vehicles, but the wookiees counter with the return of the dreaded battle tactic of swinging onto them on vines while giving a nasal Tarzan yell. That's right, once again we're reminded of the Tarzan howl that made every last one of us cringe in Return of the Jedi.

"Thank you Kashyyyk! Wookiee audiences are the best! You rock!"

Obi-Wan is tracking down General Grievous in the meantime, under the dubious rationale that if he can kill Grievous, the droids will pack up and go home. I don't know why they think assassinating one guy will end the war, but hey, it'll all end in a sword fight so who am I to complain? Eventually, he finds the planet he needs and sends his astromech droid back alone to go get backup. Then he rides a ridiculously bad-looking CG lizard creature through the city to chase Grievous down. Where did this thing come from? Did he rent it at the Hertz counter? Did it come complete with saddle? And why is it trained to respond to Obi-Wan's whistled commands? And how in the hell does he know how to ride the thing anyway?

Kenobi parks the lizard and sneaks into the building where Grievous is holed up with the other leaders of the Separatist faction. He's surrounded by dozens and dozens of battle droids and flanked by elite bodyguard droids, and in a complete cerebral failure, Obi-Wan thinks it's a good idea to somersault dead into the center of the droid mob like Errol Flynn and give a cheery "Hello!" So he does. The crack team of battle droids respond immediately to the threat and jackhammer him with blaster rifles so badly, they could bury what's left of his smoking corpse in a matchbox. Actually, the droids blandly point their guns at him, but for some reason don't waste him where he stands.

"Kill him, you witless fools!" Grievous yells, so the droids splatter the hapless Jedi all over the buffet table.

Sorry, I lied there, too. Grievous instead calls off the entire droid contingent, declaring that this time around, he's going to kill Obi-Wan in a straight-up one-on-one fight.

Damn thing needs recalibration again.

ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME? What does Dave care who kills this guy? What does he possibly have to prove? It's not like the droid army gives a damn, nor the Separatist leaders if they watch this dick-waving contest. Just have the guy KILLED! What is it with Dave and his adherence to the Bond Villain Code? UGH! Dave whips out a set of four lightsabers, one for each arm, and battles him from one side of the planet to the other. Kenobi at first seems to be at a real disadvantage, but surprisingly slaps Grievous around like a 12-foot tall redheaded stepchild. Despite Grievous' surprisingly cool strategy of lightsaber combat, Obi-Wan lops off two of his arms, driving the General to retreat. Kenobi saddles up on his trained magic riding lizard and gives chase.

Kenobi finally corners Dave, but has lost his lightsaber in the chase. Obi-Wan's not much against Dave in a fistfight, but he manages to pry open some armored panels on Dave's torso, revealing his gizzards! Hey! I didn't know Grievous had meaty bits in him. Obi Wan scoops up a blaster rifle and shoots him right in the weak spot.

No, HEARTshot!

"So uncivilized!" Kenobi grins. Aw come on, dude, you can come up with a better line than that. What about "Looks like he got a bad case of heartburn" or "That acid reflux is a killer" or "YOU LIKE THAT? HUH?? OH YEAH!! YOU LIKE THAT BITCH? I'M A JEDI! KING KONG GOT NOTHIN' ON ME! AUUUUGGGH!"

Back on Coruscant, Mace Windu is the only Jedi around who's finally starting to smell a serious rat in Chancellor Palpatine. An infuriating twist. If Anakin can sense Dooku through an entire starship, Vader can sense Kenobi on the Death Star, why can the greatest Jedi masters of all time not be able to sense the most evil son of a bitch in the galaxy sitting across the desk from them? Mace tells Anakin to go report on the status of the war to Palpatine, and report back on his reaction. The Jedi want to see whether or not Palpie will give up his emergency powers when this is all over. Mace is still being a first-class clod to him, and Anakin wanders off muttering something about setting the building on fire.

Palpatine finally comes out of the closet and confesses to being a Sith lord, sensing that it's now or never to make his last grab at the ultimate power (radar!). The two circle around each other with intense expressions, looking as if they're about to tango if only John Williams would play something spicy and seductive. Anakin's knee-jerk reaction is to waste Palpatine right there, but if you know anything about Annie, you know he doesn't have the balls. Oh, he whips it out, but he doesn't know how to use it. Instead, Annie runs off to tell the rest of the Jedi Council. Mace is outraged at the news and collects a posse of 3 other Jedi to go bring him in in an oddly thuggish fashion. He's gonna call a coupla hard pipe hittin' brothas go to work on the homes with a pair o' pliers and a blowtorch. Anakin wants to go, but Mace still continues to embarrass him and makes him go sit timeout in the council chamber.

This is one bad movie, but one baaad motherfuckin' beer, bitch!

Anakin does this, and within the span of a few seconds, the weather goes from daylight to full nighttime. Oops! Anakin finally can't take Windu's crap anymore and gets into his ship to chase after the group that's arresting Palpatine. Mace and his buddies confront Palpie in his chambers, and I'm glad he's about to die, because I really can't stand the Windu character anymore. Mace Windu is one of the worst characters in the series, and I hate to say it because I love the guy, but Samuel L. Jackson turns in one of the worst performances of the prequel trilogy here. Jackson is a superlative actor, but my issue is with his casting in this role. Samuel Jackson is a very passionate actor. His greatness comes from his ability to exude the raw emotions of anger, menace, and the threat of a violent ass-kicking in every action that he does. His acting is usually infused with emotion to such a degree, he's often shouting. Mace Windu is supposed to be a very serene man, in control of his emotions. A man nothing like Jackson is accustomed to playing. The problem is, you can't take a guy like Sam Jackson, and rob him of the tools that make him such a good actor. I keep expecting Mace to spontaneously shoot a clone trooper in the face while he's talking to Palpatine and say "Oh I'm sorry, did I break your concentration?" It's like watching Denis Leary try to play Gandhi.

"All right, mothafucka!" Mace shouts, "Get your narrow ass up against the wall and assume the position!" Actually, he just says "You're under arrest, Chancellor." Yawn.

Aaaah! Not Jedi Master Puss-in-Boots! I surrender!
This was taken when Mace was still in the academy.

Palpatine isn't impressed (neither am I) and whips out a quickdraw lightsaber from his sleeve. Cool! He rushes forward snakily and catches the Jedi off-guard, killing 3 of the masters with humiliating ease. Mace Windu looks out of his depth, but they don't call him the BMF for nothing. After a fantastic duel, Mace surprises me by knocking Sidious' lightsaber out the window and leaving him looking helpless. Anakin rushes in late, as finding a parking spot on Coruscant is a real hassle. Mace wants to kill Sidious and carve him up into crouton-sized pieces. Even the dunce Anakin has a problem with this, but Mace thinks he's too dangerous to let live to face trial because he's got so much power. He owns the Senate, the courts, and the largest chain of Starbucks in the galaxy (Come on, you had to figure Starbucks is run by an evil mastermind). I still question how virtuous these Jedi are really supposed to be if Mace Windu sees no real problem with eradicating his enemies out of convenience.

Sidious forces the issue by suddenly blasting Mace with a liberal dose of Force Lightning. Mace continues to surprise me, however, by standing his ground against the brutal assault, and even resisting it! The two are locked in a battle of wills, one that Mace seems to be winning (because he's the BMF). Palpie's starting to sweat here, begging Anakin to make the save. Palpie's putting everything he's got into the Force Lightning, and for some reason the exertion makes his flesh all pasty and lumpy. It rots his teeth and the Dark Side seems to hold him in a corner and slap him with the Ugly Stick until he can't move any more. This is the best explanation I can come up with to justify why Palpatine all of a sudden becomes a grody, fleshy dude. It all seems like Lucas is making this up as he goes along.

Anakin seems torn for a moment, but then he realizes it's a choice between the guy who's been a jerk to him for years and turned him down for the promotion, and the chance to keep banging Natalie Portman. So Annie finally grows a pair. He chops Mace's arm off and Palpie blasts him out the Windu. I mean, window.

Mace: "I just got killed by two of the whitest fools in the galaxy! Damn!"

Doesn't really make sense, but then, neither did Vader winning a pod race.

Palpatine has now evolved from a genuinely menacing Rasputin-like mentor into a leering, over-the-top parody of himself. The overacting here is so thick I'm gonna need a snow shovel to dig myself out. Sidious cackles and growls, trying so hard to be the most evil guy around, he just comes off seeming kind of silly and fun to be around. Anakin's completely whipped and swears allegiance to Sidious as long as it gives him the chance to save Padme. Neither Hayden Christensen or the script are good enough to convey the real weight this scene is supposed to have. It all seems rushed and arbitrary, as if Anakin only joins the Dark Side because the plot demands that it happen NOW. It doesn't help that Christensen has all the emotive properties of a flat tire, but not even Kenneth Branagh could elevate this drek. Not that I would compare this to Shakespeare.

Palpie declares that the Jedi are rebellious insurgents, and are now officially enemies of the state, along with Jar Jar Binks, Limp Bizkit, and Osama Bin Laden as a part of the Sith Axis of Annoying. "Once more, the Sith will rule the galaxy!" Sidious croons! "And then, the WORLD!" Er, well...okay, I made that up. He decides that Skywalker's been disrespected with the name "Annie" for too long, and thinks of something more likely to put fear in the hearts of men. So he names him Darth Bono. But Anakin doesn't like that one, and he doesn't really want to wear sunglasses all the time, so they go with Darth Vader instead. Luckily, Palpatine foregoes the usual Sith knighting ritual of whacking prospective members on the shoulders with a lightsaber like they did in medieval times. It's a tradition that was fun in the past, but tends to be considered hazing nowadays, and the third-degree burns are a real bummer. Sidious also mandates that the Jedi are too dangerous to live, so he tells Vader to go to the Jedi Temple with some clone troopers to do a sweep-and-clear. Surprisingly, Anakin doesn't so much as bat an eye at the prospect of murdering unsuspecting women, children, and other Jedi by the dozens. Is this bad scripting or bad acting? You decide!

Sidious gets on the phone and orders pizza, then transmits a galaxy-wide order to all the clone troopers everywhere to execute "Order 66." This activates some kind of sleeper program in all of the clones, and they go about shooting all the Jedi with them in the back. They even kill the hot green Twi'lek Jedi with the cute ass, much to my chagrin. Obi-Wan finds a surprising reception waiting for him at his ship, when the clone troopers nearly incinerate him with a cannon, and he falls into the ocean. Yoda's the only one to escape the trap, because he's ninja smooth. He senses the two clone troopers coming up behind him, and effortlessly decapitates them with one fluid iajutsu strike!

"For quiet time, make it Suntory time."

Darth Vader storms the Jedi Temple and comes across the Younglings. A particularly cute one says in an adorable cockney accent "Wut we gowna do?" like Oliver Twist going back up to the counter and asking "Please sir, ah won sum moah!" Vader fires up his lightsaber and chops them into sashimi. What a guy.

Obi-Wan manages to escape his assassination attempt, of course, by using his handy Sharper Image underwater breather device to swim away from the clone troopers. MAN that thing is handy, isn't it? Yoda decides that it's time for him to make tracks since it appears that the shit has officially hit the galactic fan. Chewbacca gives him a piggyback ride into the forest, where an escape pod is waiting. And just where in the hell did that come from? SINCE F-ING WHEN? Is it a naturally-occurring escape pod plant that grows wild in the forests of Kashyyyk? Yoda looks back to his faithful wookiee companions. "Goodbye, Chewbacca! Miss you, I will." Why is Chewbacca here? Anyone? Help me.

Anakin goes back to see Padme and explains that the Jedi are rebelling against the Republic. Natalie Portman has the emotional range of a traffic light in this scene, and expresses mild disbelief at the news that the Jedi are threatening to take over. Anakin tells her not to worry (although she lacks the capacity to emote "worried"), and he's going over to end the war once and for all. He's on orders from Sidious that he's to go kill the leaders of the Separatist movement, along with that frigging annoying Trade Federation twerp, Nute Gunray. Slowly, inexorably, Portman manages to contort her face into sadness, but she can't hold the emotion long, so the camera quickly cuts away.

Oh quit whining, you fat fuck.

Obi-Wan and Yoda hook up back on the familiar consular ship from A New Hope with Senator Bail Organa. Evidently, the Jedi Temple is broadcasting a distress beacon, requesting all Jedi hightail it back home ASAP, and to bring a dish to pass. Yoda left all his Tupperware at home, and Obi-Wan smells a trap. Yoda "hmmmms" in consternation and says "Suggest dismantling the coded signal, do you?" Jesus. Even though it's quite clearly an ambush, the two Jedi gleefully walk straight into it. They hack their way through a group of troopers and storm the ruined Jedi Temple, finding the aftermath of Vader's slaughter. They realize that some of them were killed by a lightsaber, and soon discover from the security videos that it was Anakin. Obi-Wan decides to go to the computer room and change that distress signal into one warning the Jedi away from Coruscant. Wise move, Kenobi. He tinkers with the computers for a while, and eventually, one of the machines changes color.

"For the clones to discover the recalibration, a long time it will take!" Yoda says. Dear lord, are you serious with this nonsense? Yoda, dude, just talk normal for a change. You're really overdoing it. And yeah, the brain-dead clones won't notice the one obviously green machine in a room full of bright blue machines. Idiot.

Palpatine has decided that enough is enough, and it's time for him to officially assume power. He holds a meeting of the Republic Senate. "The attempt on my life has left me scarred and disfigured!" he snarls in his EEEEEVIL voice. "It's inexplicably made me lumpy, given me gingivitis, and has added 75% more bass and reverb to my voice! And they also forced me to wear yellow contact lenses!" He appoints himself Emperor, to a standing ovation from the entire Senate.

Palpatine: I think I'll strip you of all your political power and impose a dictatorship on you!

Crowd: Yayyyyy! Democracy is overrated! Yayyyy!

Padme looks on from her skybox. Or at least I think it's Padme. With the complete lack of screen presence there, she might as well be a cardboard standee from Spencer's Gifts. The worst line in the movie is awarded to Natalie Portman, as she struggles to out-act a roll of linoleum: "So this is how liberty dies, with thunderous applause."

Vader's got the strong pimp hand.

Just to prove to you how bad Natalie Portman is in this movie, and how bad the dialogue is, I'll tell you what happened next. And I swear on my mother that this true. A kid in the front row of the theater projectile vomited all over himself, the floor, the seats, and the nearby people. The sound of this kid blowing chunks filled the theater to the collective horror of all present, and a dread feeling crept over the room as we anticipated the oncoming putrid stench soon to come. There I sat, vomit pooling on the floor not thirty feet from me, the stank air thick with the smell of regurgitated Spaghetti-Os, watching some of the worst acting I've ever seen. I just wanted you to know that for two reasons: (1) the effect this movie is apparently having on the weaker-willed, and (2) so you know this isn't just another gratuitous puke picture. Hah!

See, a real man would have held her hair back.

Okay, maybe just a little bit.

Obi-Wan heads over to Padme's pad and tells her that Anakin is a raving psychopathic murderer.

"He's Robert Blake?" she says incredulously.

"No, he's a Sith lord!"

Padme doesn't really believe Obi-Wan about this whole Sith Bad thing. Maybe you should have brought the video tape of him turning the preschool into an abattoir, dumbass.

Meantime, Anakin lands on the volcanic lava planet where all the Separatist leaders are chilling out. So to speak. It's gettin' hot in here, so take off all yo robes! You can tell that Anakin's evil because he's taken to scowling and wearing a hood.

Padme skedaddle after Anakin, dragging Artoo behind. Obi-Wan in a rather ingenious move hides out in the bathroom, hitching a ride in her spacecraft. Sure enough, she unwittingly leads Kenobi straight to Anakin. Of course, now that he's joined the Dark Side, Anakin is nuttier than elephant shit, and he's already expounding his ambitions to whack Palpatine and rule the galaxy himself. Portman and Christensen's acting here is worse than the shows I used to put on with my Star Wars action figures as a kid, where Slave 1 would routinely land on C-3PO for no apparent reason while Han Solo traded shots with Ewoks. And Han always won. Anyway, Anakin outlines his whole wicked plan, and Obi-Wan (standing at the top of the ship's ramp) overhears everything.

Anakin's outraged that Padme appears to have brought Obi-Wan here, because Sith lords are notorious for being jealous and having trust issues. He gets so mad, he Force Chokes Padme out. Padme struggles against the invisible grip, and Kenobi shouts "Let her go!" like there's any chance Vader is going to listen to him. He probably should have just done a running dropkick off the top of that ramp, but I'm inclined to violence most of the time. Obi-Wan finally interjects himself and gets up in Vader's grille. "Whassup?" Anakin fronts. "Whassup with YOU?" counters Obi-Wan. "Kick yo ass!" is the riposte.

"If you're not with me," Vader sneers, "you're my enemy." And the political subtext crashes all over the audience like a falling piano.

Subtext makes Dubya's head all hurty!

Actually, I doubt it's an intentional indictment of the Bush policy on terror. There's a difference between a built-in message, and drawing your own conclusions from the movie and topical subjects of the day. Besides, you're crediting George Lucas with the ability to include complex symbolism and even satire in his script. Do you really think he's smart enough to do that?

Anyway, Obi-Wan doesn't care much for that "with me or against me" rationale. "Only Sith deal with absolutes!" he shouts.

Really? Only Sith do that? I don't remember Yoda talking about a Gray Side to the Force. Seems to me that most of Jedi dogma is drawn along very clear demarcations. Light Side/Dark Side, Jedi/Sith, Stuffing/Potatoes, Tastes-Great/Less-Filling, Control/Passion, Selfishness/Selflessness, Regular or Decaf. Then again, we are talking about a religion centered on midichlorians.

In Dooku We Trust.

Vader's had enough of Obi-Wan's preaching, and they rumble in an absolutely incredible fight sequence that will no doubt go down in history as perhaps one of the best scenes of any of the movies. The choreography and score are top-notch here. The two hammer each other all over the installation with the lava roaring all about them. Anakin catches Kenobi's throat with his hand and starts to choke him out with wrist muscles exercised to superhuman levels from his many, many years of wanking off. Actually it's his mechanical hand, but I still bet he chokes the wampa with it. The planet is going absolutely apocalyptic around them, for reasons unknown. It's as if the planet itself knows that it should spark off the volcanic Armageddon to be dramatically appropriate to the script. The installation starts collapsing around them, and the two warriors find themselves battling on very tenuous ground, surrounded on all sides by spraying lava. It gets so insane on the planet, I was actually wondering why they both didn't call a bit of a timeout to find someplace a little more stable to finish the fight.

Back on Coruscant, Yoda takes it upon himself to put an end to Darth Sidious personally, Charles Bronson style. He storms into the throne room, bitchslaps the two royal guardsmen into the wall with the Force, and tells Sidious to come get him some. Sidious shrugs, stands up, and puts enough voltage into the Muppet to jumpstart a Star Destroyer. Yoda rockets backwards into the wall and crumples in a burlap heap. Sidious gloats over his apparent victory, and instead of dropping the People's Elbow on Yoda like he ought to, he sasses long enough for Yoda to get his bearings and whip out that lightsaber of his. Yoda and Palpie have themselves a donnybrook all over the Senate chamber; another grandiose and fantastic battle ranging the entire length of the sweeping spectacle of the Senate. Palpie realizes he can't take Yoda in a swordfight, because Yoda's too ninja. So he starts hurling those huge hovercars from all over the room at Yoda. Yoda goes on the defensive, doing all he can to dodge the mechanical mayhem. Palpatine really looks like he's enjoying himself, and the whole time the battle's taking place, he's laughing his wrinkly ass off. Being a Sith lord is way more fun than you'd think! Eventually, he gets on an even footing with Palpie once more and they lock themselves in a battle of wills, struggling over control of Force Lightning. To my shock, Yoda LOSES the struggle and gets hurled sickeningly to the floor far below.

I know!

Injured and defeated, Yoda crawls off to hide, muttering "Too old for this shit, I am." He decides (rather oddly) that he has failed and he will go into exile. Why wouldn't he just make a new lightsaber and help the Rebellion lead the struggle against the Emperor? He gets beaten in one close fight, and he decides to go into retirement? Some Jedi master you are.

Can someone explain to me now why, in the span of twenty years, Yoda goes from being the ultimate ninja master with a lightsaber to utterly decrepit and physically useless? And if Palpatine is also able to fight on a level close to Yoda's, why should the passage of years make him completely unable to resist Vader plucking him up over his head like a child in Return of the Jedi and tossing him into the abyss?

Vader and Obi-Wan are still clubbing each other back on the lava planet, only now, the building they were in has collapsed. Now they're battling atop a river of lava, balanced precariously on metal platforms and flying droids with flat heads that are appropriate for videogame platforming fun. Obi-Wan leaps onto a high outcropping of rock, because he's smart enough to get the hell away from the LAVA. Anakin stares laser beams at Obi-Wan and readies to attack, but Kenobi tries to warn him off. "I have the higher ground!" he shouts! But Vader isn't hearing it. He super-leaps up in the air and runs straight into Obi-Wan's upward arcing strike, cleaving both his legs and his arm off in one flawless stroke! Three limbs in ONE shot! DAAAAAAAMN!! And the bummer of it is, nobody's ever gonna believe this when Obi-Wan tells them!

I even have to compliment the acting here at last. FINALLY there's some real emotion here as a tortured Obi-Wan howls "You were the Chosen One!!" while Anakin croaks in impotent rage at his feet. It's great stuff. Then I'm horrified to see that instead of taking Anakin back with him for treatment, or even putting him out of his misery, he lets the lava rise and watches as Anakin fries to a crisp in front of him! Oh my GOD! I can't believe what I'm seeing here. I thought...I thought you were friends! I thought you were a Jedi! A good guy! You just watched while a helpless man cooked, and then left him for dead! Jesus!!

Kashyyyk. I can't believe I'm still on Kashyyyk.

Obi-JERK Kenobi leaves the planet with Padme, who appears to be dying. The medical droid solemnly approaches Kenobi and Senator Organa and says that there's nothing physically wrong with her, but she's dying anyway. "She's lots the will to live," the droid surmises. What the hell? Here's a tip, you dumb metal shit, maybe it's the crushed trachea. This movie is REALLY pissing me off now. But I guess Lucas wants us to roll with the notion that Padme is dying of sadness, so let's just go with that for now. Then why in the FUCK is Padme smiling the whole time as she sees her newborn twins??? One of the most special, beautiful, happy moments of her life, no doubt, and she doesn't seem the least bit brokenhearted. There are a thousand ways we could have killed Padme off, and Lucas went with sadness? So much for Leia knowing anything about her "real mother," huh? Suck it, George.

Elsewhere, Palpatine has found Darth Vader (who's not quite dead) and has some surgeons fit him with some new clothes. And arms and legs. And lungs. And firewire ports. Vader staggers to his new metal feet, and asks in James Earl Jones' trademark voice where Padme is. Palpatine gets an "uhhhh" look on his face, then improvises that in his rage, he accidentally killed her. Anakin protests that he remembers not doing that, but seeing as how he's still a complete dope, eventually takes Palpatine's line of B.S. hook, line, and sinker. Vader looks up to the sky and screams "NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!" issuing unintentional laughs from me. I had no idea this was coming, and it just sounded completely hilarious that Vader would have a Shatner moment like this.

Jones' delivery of the line is terrible, but I think it's more that a scream is completely out of character for Darth Vader (the guy in the black suit we know from the original trilogy). Vader has a lot of rage, but it's not the overt SCREAMING type of rage. He seethes, he threatens, he's bold and blunt. And even when he loses control of himself and lashes out in violence, his voice remains relatively calm and cold. Even when Vader is vulnerable before Luke ("It is...too late for me...") he doesn't give in to tortured screams of internal torment. I know that we're talking about a character who has just lost the love of his life, but...I don't know. It doesn't sound right coming through that mask.

And so we come to the end of the movie. Obi-Wan, Yoda, and Bail Organa meet up to decide what to do with the Skywalker twins. Obi-Wan decides he'll take Luke to the Skywalker family on Tatooine, Organa will take Leia back home to Alderaan, the droids get their memories wiped, and they tell Yoda to go piss off in a swamp somewhere. Yoda pulls Kenobi aside first, and tells him that he knows of a way to cheat death, in a way. He says that his old master, Qui-Gon Jinn has mastered the technique of living on in an incorporeal form, and he offers to teach this technique to Obi-Wan. And yet we don't see a single solitary second of Liam Neeson! What a rip!!

Okay, so let's run this down. Yoda knows how to become a shimmering blue ghost, Obi-Wan knows how to become a shimmering blue ghost. So who taught Anakin?

Oopsie!

Aaaaaaaah!

Vader goes through a lengthy process of rehab. The shocker of the movie comes when I see a guest cameo by a guy who looks exactly like Peter Cushing in the role of (soon to be) Grand Moff Tarkin! How cool is that?? Now is the time on Star Wars when we dance!

It's Bib Fortuna's Dance Party!

All images blatantly stolen from a terrific RottenTomatoes Photoshop contest. Unfortunately I don't have the creators' names, so if you'd like to take credit for your work, e-mail me and I'll make sure your work is recognized.

{ 49 comments }

Ken348 August 11, 2009 at 12:25 am

Great review Spoony!

I hate it how when I tell people I don’t own any of the Star Wars prequels they always say, “ah, well Revenge of the Sith wasn’t so bad.” Bullshit! This movie sucked ass as much as the other two crappy prequels!

Me and my friends were so disappointed with this movie that we spent the next two hours at Denny’s just ripping into it. Ah, good times…

Buzzkill killer August 11, 2009 at 8:17 am

Great work spoony, very entertaining review! personally i didn’t mind the prequels but thats probably because i treat the franchise as any softcore fan treats trek; detached and amusedly entertained. I’m sorry for the forthcoming stupidity but why is Menace treated as though it was “It” to the knights of Ni? i though it was rather alright (Liam Neeson is GOD),… ‘cept for jake lloyd, he shall be fed to beeelzebub 1 pound per year for ETERNITY!

J-Naps August 11, 2009 at 10:43 am

Wow, another amazing review.

The only thing this movie had going for it was McGregor. Portman just looked bored to be there, Jackson was passable at best. I saw the movie opening night and laughed out loud at Palpatine’s “NO…Noooo…YOU WILL DIE!!!”

All I could think of at that point was Shao Kahn. Thank you George Lucas for raping my childhood once again.

johnnyfog August 11, 2009 at 6:25 pm

I thought the Vader / Obi-Wan fight paled in comparison to the Palpatine / Yoda fight. You just felt a lot more drama and tension in that senate chamber, as opposed to Mustafar which is composed entirely of spewing lava and loud orchestras.

Granted, I liked it when I saw it. But playing Jedi Force Acedemy, with the Sith Lords tossing their lightsabers like boomerangs and doing anti-grav stunts, I can’t help but feel ROTS wasn’t creative enough with the fight sequences. Even the duel with Grievous was cooler.

Jachra August 11, 2009 at 7:17 pm

The prophecy to bring Balance to the Force is destroying the Sith, it has nothing to do with numbers of Jedi vs. numbers of Sith. It was fulfilled when Darth Vader chucked Emperor Palpatine into the pit in Episode 6.

…mind you, the prequels suck anyway, so who cares? And yes, he wrote the prophecy AFTER the fact of production to reflect what would happen in Episode 6.

Ely August 11, 2009 at 10:54 pm

when you started talking about the kid puking at natalie portman i couldn’t stop laughing hahah, good good stuff. when the emperor got all cruddy looking i just figured because the lightning and pure power of the dark side being rejected into his face was maybe having adverse results on him. but me thinks it was a pretty great review, thanks!

Ely August 11, 2009 at 10:56 pm

oh and also, i hated it when palpatine fought in this movie. whenever you could tell it was the actual actor the fight scene was really slow and was full of poses, but when it was a far away view where they could use cg thats when the fight was great. example, when he first starts dueling yoda it’s a weird looking battle full of like… slow stuff i guess, but when the music score kicks in and the elevator is rising up and it’s a far away view then it’s a pretty epic saber duel.

DaftRaider42 August 12, 2009 at 6:41 am

It’s as if a million voice cried ouot in terror and were suddenly silenced. Actually, I kinda liked this film, despite the wooden acting and poor script, but hey, at leat it wasn’t as bad as the ‘I hate sand…’ speech from AOTC. Now that was torture.

Destrucity August 12, 2009 at 3:08 pm

The guys from Rifftrax put it best…

Mike Nelson: “Today we will be taking on Revenge of the Sith, widely acknowledged to be the best film of the new trilogy.”

Bill Corbett: “True, Mike, but that’s like saying ‘Of the three times it’s happened, that was the best time I got stung in the eye by a wasp.’”

jadedcorliss August 13, 2009 at 5:32 pm

Hmm, he’s upset by the physics and unlikely fighting/killing in Star Wars.

LOL

The most insane thing in Star Wars is how if Luke kills the Emperor, then he turns bad, but he destroyed an entire station with millions of workers and scientists earlier and that was considered to be a good thing. And when Vader kills the emperor, it makes him good. Luke can mow down troops, but killing the worst bad guy who he has to kill is somehow bad.

The physics and likelyhood of so much of the original films makes no sense either, we literally see a locked on shot fired several times and yet he doesn’t get hit, with very conveniant timing.

jadedcorliss August 13, 2009 at 5:34 pm

Still, the whole raped my childhood thing also makes no sense to me.

jadedcorliss August 13, 2009 at 5:37 pm

Plus, you can get the original films unaltered just fine on DVD.

Kardinal August 13, 2009 at 7:01 pm

Yeah, the balance thing is supposed to mean “no Sith” – which is either an incredibly clumsy retcon (which wouldn’t be the first) or Lucas really should look up the word balance.

Bad movie overall and the only things I could enjoy were the fight scenes and McDiarmid delivering ham and cheese super-sized. Anakin’s heel turn is supposed to be more believable in the books but that shouldn’t come as a surprise when Keanu Reeves can deliver more emotional depth then you two main actors.

But hey, at least the Jedi lightsaber duels are not interrupted for the Gungan’s Three Stooges act or Jake Lloyd talking.

IronyPulse132 August 14, 2009 at 4:33 am

One funny thing is how the hell did Revenge of the Sith get a higher score than Return of the Jedi in Rottentomatoes and Metacritic? It’s like some sort of fucking joke. Return of the Jedi doesn’t even compare to this.

Anyways, that final scene with Padme dying is pathetic. HELLO, SHE DIED FROM SUFFOCATION! I don’t think Natalie Portman is a bad actress, she’s just given a terrible script. Overall, 3 is the best out of the prequels, but still, that’s not saying much.

adsfrasdfasf August 26, 2009 at 5:45 pm

I loved all 6 Star Wars films!

adsfrasdfasf August 26, 2009 at 5:46 pm

The prequels were good films!

Raith August 31, 2009 at 12:03 pm

Very funny review! Me and my friends were huge SW fans. And our group just got smaller with each movie. Episode 1 had 7 of us go together. Episode 2 4 or us and just 2 showed for Episode 3.

The acting and story were bullsh!t to the n’th degree!! It was as if Lucas realised that he spent 2 movies playing with CG charactes and toys and forgot he’s gotta finish the story, so he crammed it all into the 3rd one. It just felt so rushed and made little sense. How does Anakin go against years of training and essentially being a good guy to turn into a kid murdering sith slave…the very people he swore to destroy…in the span of 1 second?!?!??

“What have I done???”
Don’t worry, Annie…you’ll get over it…like RIGHT NOW.

I don’t know…there’s tons wrong with this film and it’s like beating a dead horse at this point. However, it is indeed the best of the new trilogy. Such a sad fact.

Yerfdog September 1, 2009 at 3:41 pm

I enjoyed the prequels. I don’t get why everyone hates them so much. Sure the original trilogy is better, but I still like the prequels. Or at least episodes 1 and 3.

Anuojat September 3, 2009 at 10:26 am

Cant quite agree with you spoony, in my opinion this 3 was good movie. I couldnt finad anything laughable about it… thats not to say i like episodes 1 and 2. No, those two didnt really get it. This one did, for me anyway… lucky i guess since there seems to be an awful lot people making fun of the prequals… :S

PS. The only thing in this movie that i found dissappointing were several lines. Cheesy yeah, about 6 lines which didnt work, otherwise i didnt get too serious, i just watched it without any critical eye, i dont enjoy movies that way.

f16134 September 5, 2009 at 4:51 pm

I actually fell asleep watching this movie (in my house of course XD).

Flayer September 5, 2009 at 9:09 pm

Great review, Spoony.

And the man who played Tarkin was Wayne Pygram, the actor who played Scorpius in Farscape. Fuck that was such a great show; shame they canceled it.

greensucksbluerules September 13, 2009 at 1:00 pm

I actually fell asleep while trying to read this “review.”

Carnage1235 September 23, 2009 at 11:19 am

I didn’t really hate the prequels, and this probably was the best of the three of them. I thought Ewan Mcgregor did a suprisingly true and actually very good performance as Obi-wan, and I do have to admit some happiness in noticing how much he resembled the future Alec Guinness. Also, I don’t really know why, but I really liked the guy playing Bail Organa, he just fit, thats all I can say, he just fit. I don’t think Natalie Portman is a bad actor, I just think they fucked up her lines. And I do see what you mean about the Yoda “I can’t be bothered to speak correctly cause i’m Yoda bitch!” personality trait into actual speech. Like he actually put THOUGHT into talking like that. Hayden Christensen was just a very bland actor (until when he was being burnt by the lava), but it was still more bearable then fucking Jake Lloyyds “You’re a jedi too? Pleased to meet ya!” line in The Phantom menace. Overall I myself would probably rate it, maybe, 2 and a half stars out of 5. Not a great movie, not really even good, but its not terrible, its not actually THAT bad, just you know, not great. But fucking Jar-Jar, I just wanted to hit him with a rake, but apparently he died on Alderaan in Episode 4, so, I think we got our wish. (But that IS just a rumour).

warman40k September 29, 2009 at 7:26 pm

I hated the frist two prequels. One had two bad actors, a pointless Pod-racing sence, a creepy underage romance, and killed Liam Neeson off ( say what you will, I thought he was good.) Two had Anakin acting like a complete dumbass (I need to go Emo again!), and, again, a horrible romance sub-plot. Three was a good movie, but not a good Star Wars movie. Hayden was a bad actor, and so was Natalie, at least to a certin extent. I also though how the Republic just had a brain fart when the Sith said “Hi, We’re going to fuck you over! Have a nice day!”
But, I guess, like you, I was entertained. I just had to turn off my brain. But when I go to a Star Wars movie, I don’t want to. Episode four did a great myth. adaptation. As well has Episode 5 and 6, to a lesser extent. Lucas chose story and concepts over flashy effets, and it payed off. Not so with the pequals. He just lost it, and, i the shit-fest CGI movie, (one of the few movies to make me phyically angry), he’ll never, ever get it back.

Vidaluko October 1, 2009 at 8:30 pm

Great review Spoony, I would love to see this in video, but hey, is Spoony text edition….

I liked all movies, but Episode 1 and 2 are worth the first time you see them, and maybe never again, while 3, 4, 5 and 6 I have seen them like 3 times in all my life, the action scenes in Episode 3 are great, the intro was great, when you see the 2 little space ships of Obi and Anakin, then they go down and there are thousands of ships in war, awesome, and actually the action scenes in Episode 2 are good to (and the last battle in Episode 1) but the love scenes in 2 ruin the movie, I know Lucas wants to show how they fall in love and all that, but they sux, the last scene in the arena with all the Jedis is great, anyway, great review Spoony….

Screeble371 October 7, 2009 at 6:31 am

lol very nice review , I had much the same opinion of this movie, the best of the prequels indeed.i saw jake lloyd at a sci fi convention recently where he did a q&a session and he got so pissed of when anyone asked about episode 1, i think even he is embarassed about it too,(he is something like 21 yrs old now) imagine looking back at that performance as a grown up, and it’s all anyone asks about? ahh poor guy

jojotogi October 11, 2009 at 10:53 pm

Spot on SpoonyOne.

Yeah. i wanted more of the Clone Wars in the prequel. No one gave a damn about the politics and bullshit in Episode 1. But unfortunately, because that one only had marginally to do with the Clone Wars, we got to see less of the massive conflict that everyone had speculated for 20 plus years over.

And, you know what just occurred to me. Anakin is so emo. Really, he is. He mopes around all day, wears dark clothes, rebels against his parental figures and gets his arm cut…off.

Sifer2 October 17, 2009 at 6:36 pm

It’s true this is the only half good prequel. Though at least the first movie had Darth Maul who was neat. But still this is the only one that really approaches being worth considered a Star Wars film. I especially like the opening which really feels like a Star WAR for once. An the ending fights are satisfying. But yeah the acting is most of the time unforgivably terrible. Like Lucas just assumed its a kids movie an they wont notice. Likewise despite having 3 movies to make the transition believable an gradual when Anakin finally does switch sides it feels too rushed to be believable. I mean I can see him half accidently helping kill Windu an feeling scared like he needs to be a Sith now to survive an help Padme. But to immediately sink to the point of obeying everything he is told to the point of killing innocent children? It’s just too much.

The closing parts of the film are also strange in that it both drags on too long and is also too rushed. Kind of like Return of the King’s ending. So many damn cut aways to a new place an scene ugh. An Padme dying in child birth does sort of create a plot hole but then there are plenty already made by the prequels. I also agree I felt shafted not getting to see Qui Gon as a ghost. At least the ending shot of the Tatooine sunset was probably the perfect closure.

Mr.Stillman October 19, 2009 at 12:40 am

I couldn’t agree with you more, “Spoony”. Actually, I agree with your friends (“it was Ok”) too, but I agree with you even moreso. Actually, it may be “Ok”, but this is supposed to be freakin’ Star Wars!

Since you didn’t touch on this, I would like to bring something up: I saw a thing on TV about workers on the set bragging about how there is all this stuff going on in the back ground. The PROBLEM is, human beings only have one attentional spotlight. ONE. So if you are looking at someone’s face in the foreground, you are TOTALLY ignoring all that million dallar jazz in the background. NO ONE notices it, so it may as well not even be there. The only way it is possible to see that stuff is if you ignore the main characters and action in the foreground which is kind of a stupind thing to do since the story is riding on them. Stupid idiots! I learned about the human attentional spotlight in a second year psychology course and these millionaires all think we have multiple attenion spans. Well we don’t. Countless experiments have shown that we can only really focus on one thing at a time. Multi-tasking is simply swithcing back and forth from one thing to another.

“Am I just watching a cartoon now?” Spoony, I really hate to inform you, but you’ve been watching a cartoon since Phantom Menace.

And Mace is just there because he is black and the politically correct thing to do is make the most high up powerful intellect in the franchise a bald black man. You know it, I know it, we all know it. And why Samuel to play the role? Because he costs the most money and the goal of this movie is to cost as much money as possible.

I think you should have mentioned the overly obvious symbolism: a gaint red square light over the emperor’s left shoulder, him standing next to an actual devil with actual horns, the lava at the end is obviously representing anger and destruction, and so on. The fight with the emperor was obviously Yoda trying to stabilize the government while the emperor was wrecking it down, and they went with doing it all literally because we are all stupid idiots.

You seem to praise the fight scene at the end, but I thought those dinky skateboard things they were standing on looked like….dinky skateboards.

Obi Wan probably did not rescue his “friend” because he is a child killer and he also wiped out all the Jedi, remember? It’s not like Obi Wan has to go home and report stuff like usual anymore. I also think you are wrong about the fight scenes going down as some of the best. It’s too fake; you don’t even see them sweating or panting after 10 minutes of constant fighting or w/e it was…next to LAVA!! Wearing heavy robes!!! I don’t remember now, but I bet their hair is perfect.

Anyway, great review of this piece of garbage movie. Sigh. We KNOW nothing bad is going to happen to Yoda Chewi and Obi Wan. There is no danger at all because we all know they are alive in parts 4-6. So there is no point in these movies even existing. Some of the CG is the worst I have ever seen and it angers me that they tossed this much money into these worthless movies.

Lotus Prince October 21, 2009 at 11:27 am

You know what really made me mad about this movie?

1. The Obi-Wan and Grievous fight. Such bullshit. It’s exactly like what Episode 2 did to us. Woah, Anakin has TWO lightsabers! This oughta be…oh, he got an arm cut off. Oh, Grievous uses FOUR lightsabers? This is…oh, he lost an arm. But still, three arms is…oh, he lost another arm. I mean, seriously, what the hell. Also, if you’ve ever watched the animated Clone Wars series (the good one, by Genndy Tartakovsky), then you’d see that Grievous is an absolute demon with four lightsabers, and it is truly, truly entertaining to watch.

2. Yoda looks noticeably younger in the prequels. Why? The prequels are what, twenty years before the original trilogy? Yoda is approaching NINE HUNDRED YEARS of age. He shouldn’t actually LOOK much younger twenty years ago. What is twenty years when compared to nine hundred? Really, you suck, Lucas. Also, not only does Yoda apparently have a good rapport with the Wookies, but he also seems to know Chewbacca on a personal level. Seriously, what the hell are the odds? I thought Solo saved Chewie from some slave ship, or something. Should he have even been ON Kashyyyk at the time?

Lotus Prince October 21, 2009 at 11:43 am

Oh yeah, and I forgot to mention that the books say that Palpatine looks old and haggard from his exposure to the dark side of the Force. But I didn’t think that that meant he’d turn gray and wrinkly in the span of six seconds.

Also, that “only Sith deal in absolutes” is an utterly retarded statement, because the statement itself is absolute.

humanist October 24, 2009 at 8:02 am

Another great review, Noah. Nowhere near as great, in my opinion, as the movie itself, of course, or the other two prequels, but very entertaining nonetheless.

“It’s just…over for them. They’re DONE. They just can’t take it any more. They’re not even able to steel themselves to ride out this crummy trilogy as it crashes down in flames, like they said they would at first.”
This, and the next several sentences of the paragraph (the entire middle of the paragraph, basically) perfectly describes my reaction to “Legacy of the Force.”

“Considering how badly they got their asses handed to them the last time, Anakin and Kenobi decide (rather unfairly, in my opinion) to double-team Dooky.”
I know you’re making fun of the name here, but you would not believe the number of times I’ve written it that way as a typo.

‘… Imagine what the prequels would’ve looked like if they’d killed off Palpatine halfway through and we’d been left with Darth Maul or Count Dooky as the main villain …’

*slaps forehead*
‘Shit! I meant Dooku. Doo-kU!’

“Interestingly, Dooku does not explode in a rush of dark side energies like every other Sith lord I’ve seen.”

What? Hold the phone here. Let’s run a checklist here:

Darth Sidious/Emperor Palpatine: Yes
Darth Vader: No
Darth Maul: No

No fair bringing in the Expanded Universe, but the only example I can recall from there is Joruus C’Baoth, who wasn’t even a Sith Lord. (Apart from “Jedi Knight,” I’ve never played any of the games, though. Maybe they do that in “Knights of the Old Republic”?)

Whaddya mean “every other Sith Lord”?

“think about this. Just for a second. Count the number of Jedi in the galaxy. Good. Big number, yeah? Now count the number of Sith. One, maybe two? Now how do you balance this equation? One of two ways: decrease the number of Jedi, or increase the number of Sith.”

Oh please. Not you, too. Come on Noah, you’re smarter than this. I mean, I disagree with you on most of these points, but to be this dense, you’d have to be trying to find problems with the prequels.

The prophecy, as repeated throughout all three movies, states that the Chosen One will bring balance to the FORCE, not (and this is important) to the NUMBER of Jedi and Sith. It’s debatable what “balance to the Force” is, but it’s safe to assume that an equal number of Jedi and Sith (arbitrary organizations set up by Force-users, not the Force itself) it is not.

In Western societies, we’re brought up to think of “balance” in terms of the “balance between good and evil,” but if we think of evil instead as a perversion of life, then Lucas definition of eliminating evil (the Sith) could indeed restore “balance.”

Besides which, this interpretation of the prophecy makes as little sense as (you claim) characters’ actions and events in the prequels do. Why would the Jedi put such great faith in a prophecy which says “A Chosen One will arise, and will bring balance to the Force … and then, only twenty-five years later, he will throw it right out of balance again”? (Remember, at the end of the saga, we’re left with 0 Sith, 1 Jedi and 1 potential Jedi, and so much for balance between the number of Jedi and Sith.)

“As soon as Jake Lloyd walked into the council chamber, you should have leapt out of your beanbag chair, fired up your lightsaber, and chopped him into crinkle fries.”
Not that there’d be any danger of falling to the Dark Side after killing a defenseless, unthreatening little kid like that (even if you do find him annoying). None whatsoever.

“Mace Windu is supposed to be a very serene man, in control of his emotions.”
Not if you read Matthew Stover, who wrote the movie’s novelization and the Clone Wars novel “Shatterpoint” about Mace Windu. Looking it from your perspective, you might say that Stover is trying to harmonize the Windu character to the actor. Myself, I think they fit very well together, but then, I don’t think I’ve really seen Jackson in any other movies, so what do I know?

“I still question how virtuous these Jedi are really supposed to be if Mace Windu sees no real problem with eradicating his enemies out of convenience.”
Totally agree with you, of course, but what was that you were saying about Yoda a minute ago?

“The worst line in the movie is awarded to Natalie Portman, as she struggles to out-act a roll of linoleum: ‘So this is how liberty dies, with thunderous applause.’”
Ha-ha, that’s always been one of my favorites. And I don’t mean to snark at, I mean that I think it’s a genuinely good line. I might as well also mention at this point that I thought the acting in this movie was passable. At worst.

I also had a problem with the way they killed of Padmé, but I object because it was just so blatantly sexist. Just about the only thing about this movie I did find problematic.

Anaphyis October 30, 2009 at 7:53 am

“Totally agree with you, of course, but what was that you were saying about Yoda a minute ago?”

A joke?

As for the whole balance argument: Balance implies opposing forces in an equilibrium, in any conceivable definition and this includes eastern philosophy – think yin and yang – which also has balance between good and evil. If Lucas simply said “Harmony” this whole prophecy business would be somehow acceptable because it is vague enough for Yoda to be concerned about the true meaning and Qui Gon believing in it whole-heartedly.

As it is, all attempts to explain this massive discrepancy away by redefining the word balance obscure enough are the worst cases of fanwankery I’ve seen to emerge out of any fandom. Why? Star Wars never was incredibly deep to begin with – which is not bad in itself – and doesn’t need to be defended. I’m relatively sure Lucas is sleeping well at night on top of a large pile of money.

And it isn’t like it’s the worst the prequels have to offer; from the massive retcons, the shoehorning of original trilogy characters into anything they could find, the el cheapo CGI, the dreadful romance, the actors inability to act their way out of a taco joint and not to mention the whole premise in itself: We already know what happens to all of the characters. There is no tension. You can still pull this off if you have a good script and even better actors to make you care for the characters even if you know how he ends up, but the prequels had neither.

The big questions the fandom had for the prequels were: “Whats that about the clone wars” and “Why did Anakin become Darth Vader?” The former isn’t really answered and the latter comes down to “Be evil! – Noooooo! – Be evil! – ‘kay”

humanist November 9, 2009 at 3:02 pm

@ Anaphyis: Oh, I realize it was a joke, but when he says, e.g. “The worst line in the movie is awarded to Natalie Portman, as she struggles to out-act a roll of linoleum,” we assume he means it. Sure he exaggerates for the sake of humor, but it wouldn’t be a joke if he didn’t also believe that Natalie Portman’s acting was subpar during this scene. (I’ve noticed, Noah, that you tend to spend a substantially greater amount of time disparaging women’s acting than men’s.)

“Balance implies opposing forces in an equilibrium,”
I’m not so sure it always implies that, but since I can’t think of any obvious counterexamples, we’ll let that stand for the sake of argument, with the proviso that we do not necessarily take “opposing” to mean “diametrically opposed.” You can have equilibrium between three equal forces coming together at 120 degree angles, or a whole bunch of forces coming from different directions, so long as their net force vector is 0.

Even so, the balance isn’t necessarily between good and evil. That’s just our own cultural binaries talking. Lucas is part of that binary culture too, but he could be going for something else. An ecosystem could be said to be thrown out of balance/equilibrium by the introduction of an invasive species. Therefore removing that species would theoretically restore balance to the ecosystem. It’s not a perfect metaphor, and would seem to contradict Lucas’ insistence that the Dark Side (which the Sith draw on) is as integral to the Force as the Light Side. Hmm, maybe instead of neutrality, sentient beings are supposed to stick to the Light Side and leave darkness to disease and natural disasters and the like; therefore a sentient being channeling upon the Dark Side would rather muck up the divine balance.

But let’s assume you’re right, that the balance in question is between good and evil, as represented by the Jedi and Sith respectively. You still neglect the fact that Jedi and Sith are manifestations of the Force, not the other way around. Whittling away at the numbers of either organization could only affect the balance of the latter if the strength of Light Side and Dark Side were directly related to the number of Force-users drawing upon them. This certainly sounds like a bizarre set-up, and you’d think someone in one of the movies would at least have hinted at it. It also means the top priority for Jedi and Sith should’ve been to recruit as many Force-sensitive beings to their respective sides as humanly (or nonhumanly) possible to bolster their own side’s leverage, and makes the Jedi’s celibacy policy and the Sith Rule of Two infinitely stupider conventions.

Plus, I’m going to reiterate. Thousand/million-year-old prophecy which everybody puts a lot of faith and which apparently becomes fulfilled only to be reversed a mere generation later = one very lame prophecy.

Redbob86 November 14, 2009 at 4:00 am

Personally I rather enjoyed this movie, campiness and all. Personally I thought all 6 films had terrible dialogue, even though I love them.

However, I still have never been able to tolerate Hayden Christenson. People always complain about that, but few ever bother to name another actor that they think would be a more convincing Anakin. But me and my friends have agreed that Episodes 2 and 3 could’ve been significantly better if Anakin Skywalker was played by Alex Rosenbaum (Lex Luthor from the Smallville series). Darth Vader from the original series was cold and calculating, not prone to fits and self-pitty. Alex has been playing Lex Luthor for 7 years, and knows how to play a cold, uncaring, supervillian that slowly becomes more evil over time as he journies down the path of darkness while not realizing it. Plus, he looks good bald (the only hairstyle Vader had in the original trilogy).

Swing on teh Spiral December 3, 2009 at 4:33 pm

They are Lucas’ movies. he can do whatever he wants with them. I love you spoony, i really listen to you when it comes to your advice. But really? Jar Jar is that big of a threat to your childhood? you’re really letting a comic relief character get to you? the studios pushed lucasfilm to put in as many no-thought kids characters as they could fit. yeah, the gungans are kind of annoying, but they turned jar jar into a diplomat on the senate and wrote him out of the series. 3-PO wasnt any better throughout the original movies, he whined and whined and whined just like binks, he was a messed up stereotype just like binks. I LOVE Empire too, its the best sci fi movie ever. but we arent going to see anything like that again, i dont think i want to. the special effects were great in the original trilogy, from puppets to pixels, i have to admitt, henson was a master of his craft and the cgi was kind of phoned in to sell the movie. but i like natalie portman, and ewan, and samuel. sure hayden sucks, but isnt it enough to see star wars on the big screen again? im not condoning mediocrity here but an epic space opera designed for all ages… the first trilogy was just as hammy, but you were seeing something unlike anything seen before i guess, and ever since the “holy trinity” there’s been star trek films, blade runner, serenity, and an assload of other good sci fi films. all this “lucas raped my childhood” stuff is just getting sad and selfish. The prequels didnt go in a wrong direction, they went in a different direction. maybe im just a nerd thats easy to please when it comes to the star wars franchise, or at least the 2 trilogies and most of the video games i love. the shows have all sucked hard, maybe EVERY star wars fan is just in denial that all of them are kids movies. plain and simple, you were probably a kid when you saw the originals, i was a kid when i saw all of them so there were no memories to ruin, i love em all. guess thats my point.

Jamanticus December 12, 2009 at 12:33 am

Absolutely hilarious review, Spoony. I laughed through almost the entire thing- brilliant piece of writing, especially from a comedic point of view, and it’s still really good from a purely critical point of view.

And it’s really enlightening to read the comments as well. There seems to be the ‘I agree completely’ crowd, the ‘You’re pretty accurate, although there are a few things you didn’t get right with the review’ group and then the rabid ones who say ‘You’re just plain wrong.’ And they’re all great in their own ways (I guess I’m with the ‘I’ll have the chicken, then’ crowd).

(And you know something, Spoony? You write very true to the way you speak in your reviews. You know how some people have a huge gap between the way they write and the way they speak? As in, they’d be saying an expletive every other word in a spoken review, but a written review would look like it was a New York Times article wannabe? With you, there is no disconnect. Every word of your written reviews sounds like something you’d say in a live review, and it’s just really great to see that you’ve got that connection there.)

Ryan January 15, 2010 at 2:04 pm

I have to say I rather liked this movie. The murder of the jedi sequence was beautifully done. Also, the novelization’s depecition of the duel clears up most of the bullshit. Yoda was too exhausted, while Sideous was standing tall. He also realized that the sith reformed themselves to be indestructible with the jedi’s current methods, meaning they would have to grow. And anakin didn’t become weaker then palpy until after Obi Wan maimed him. They also make Anakin’s fall less stupid. In the book, he wants to be a master because it will allow him access to the holocrons (which is where the jedi keep their powerful lore and secrets.) This would give him a way to save Padme. In the book it’s more “These assholes are keeping me from a way to potentially save my beloved.” Yoda’s advice is also “Don’t be afraid to loose your loved ones.” Anakin also considers the possibility of self fullfilling prophecy but decides that saving padme is worth the risk.

In short, I loved the movie, but felt that the novel cleaned up most of the horseshit.

Andrew Michael Brown April 10, 2010 at 3:14 am

Ah yes, all charm Star Wars had was completely eradicated with those prequels…for shame…

DarthYan May 4, 2010 at 8:21 am

orignially liam neeson was going to be in it but then he got injured in a motercycle accident. and originally jabba was meant to be in episode iv, but computer limitations made it improssible. also, I find it hard to believe the original trilogy lost all appeal.

Ran88 May 6, 2010 at 6:15 pm

I really liked this movie despite HATING the first two prequels. Sure it had some really dumb parts like the whole “she died of a broken heart” bullshit but still overall its entertaining and unlike the other two prequels actually feels like star wars/

LordNoctis May 12, 2010 at 12:53 am

Well Spoony, here comes one of those times where I disagree with you. While the first two prequels are horrible, I thought this one was decent. Hardly a masterpiece, and by no means on par with the OT. But this movie is, in my opinion, a good movie. I also think Hayden's acting, while still not very good, was a big improvement over AOTC.

Also, I have a bit of a nerd issue to bring up regarding the whole 'Bring balance to the force' thing. When they say bring balance to the force, they mean destroy the dark side. You see, the dark side is itself not a natural part of the force. In its natural state the force is neutral. The dark side's origins are unknown, but its nature is like a cancer. As the sith grow in power, the dark side grows and begins to consume the force (Which is why it became harder for Yoda to read the future as the movies progressed) By destroying the sith in ROTJ, Vader severely weakened the dark side since he had just killed two of the most powerful sith in history (Palpatine, and himself)

Also, the reaosn Palpatine grew deformed was because the lightning was being deflected back into his face.

DarthYan May 26, 2010 at 11:48 am

For the record, I actually own a dvd that has the unedited theatrical release of empire strikes back. so there is hope.

spoonshock June 13, 2010 at 11:32 pm

The thing that chewed my nuts the most about this movie was the lazy “tie up all the loose plot threads in the last 20 minutes of the film” approach they went with. “Oh, by the way, Luke goes to X, Leia goes to Y, Yoda's going here, and here's a convenient explanation for the Jedi Ghosts!”

Star Wars is dead to me.

TCBLB June 22, 2010 at 11:39 pm

I agree that when the best thing to say about a movie is that it's better then the two that proceeded it, one being poorly written with an obnoxious asshole alien in it. The other being the worst thing in the history of anything with a preening and pouting little twerp whose action figures should have come with tampons, it's not high praise.

I wonder what Uwe Boll would do with Star Wars………..Hey why not, it's already ruined? Why not pour gas in the tank of an already wrecked car?

DarthYan June 28, 2010 at 7:51 am

spoony. By the dvd with the original. It's damn worth it.

DarthYan June 30, 2010 at 9:41 am

dude thats silly just pretend they are non canon

Anonymous June 30, 2010 at 4:41 pm

dude thats silly just pretend they are non canon

Anonymous August 13, 2010 at 6:03 pm

Star wars has always sucked. Even the original trilogy is godawful

Comments on this entry are closed.

blog comments powered by Disqus